xminusme
patreon
Which model is better?
🕑 Added 2024-11-05 08:27:01 +0000 UTCThe Mel-RoFormer model by unwa v2 has just been added! We're asking you to test it out and vote.
Comments
willy jack
is there a way to lay my vocals on a track?
Жалгас Есенбаев
БЛин я ж оплатил
Жалгас Есенбаев
Почему не работает
Knowledge Bey
Do you have something coming were it can separate 2 vocals?
Semih Acer
When another model will come ? Im really impatient!! Unwa v2 is not bad but I really want better
Tim Shikolenkov
My method is to use one of these, depending on the track's quality. For example, v1 gives much better results for MP3s, while v2 is better for lossless originals. Then I put the result into the denoiser.
Cristobal Ramos
Don't expect wonders. Melroformers are the BEST models out there, no doubt about it. FB338 was (for me) the best before BS and Mel appeared. Now I only use FB338, when and if I use it, for that scenario I said before, small parts with quiet instruments
Raffaela
v1 and v2 with postprocessing
deleted_user_123
Have you tested v1 or v2?
Gatto
Thanks for sharing, looking forward to trying it out!
Cristobal Ramos
Here it is, Gatto. Just drop it in the models/MDX_Net_Models folder in the Ultimate Vocal Remover installation folder, it should show up in the list of models when you start the program https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zIqoCHQyYQHz7F9mib43_vuM5psobiTO/view?usp=sharing
Raffaela
As I already said on the channel, in my opinion Kim's model is far better: the Unwa model leaves a very annoying background noise, despite the sound quality being similar.
Gatto
Sure man, no rush, take your time :)
Cristobal Ramos
Gatto, sorry, I'm still working on it (actually, I'm writing this in my laptop because the OS migration in my desktop PC went like cr*p), but the moment I can I'll send you that link
Gatto
Would be really appreciated! I also find myself with some faint vocal leftovers in a few tracks the MelRoFormer models couldn't fully isolate, so it's worth giving a shot to other models for those specific parts.
Cristobal Ramos
I downloaded it and added it to UVR (Ultimate Vocal Remover 5.6.0). You need that program to run it. Overall, the Melroformers are much better, but in some songs they still leave faint traces of the voice in the instrumental, in quiet parts. FB338 takes better care of those parts without mudding the sound, though it may add some noise, so I just use it specifically for those parts, while for the rest of the song I go with melroformer. Give me an hour (I'm migrating my OS to a new drive) and I'll link you the FB338 model to download
Gatto
Where do you access that FB338 model? I'm interested in trying it out.
Cristobal Ramos
Why choose? I would, but if that means removing one or the other I won't. The KIM model has the Demudder post-process which, depending on the song, gives better results than UNWA2, plus Max+Mag Drums. The combo Demudder/MMDrums is a killer UNWA2 doesn't seem to be that major an improvement (at least in the songs I've tried). I'm still using FB338 in some songs because, in some parts, still works better than the new models, and was removed from site. I wouldn't like the same happening to any of the Mel-Roformers at all
Gatto
Both seem to sound equivalent if I'm honest. What made v1 special is the amount of muddiness it eliminated from the old model, hopefully it'll be a step forward in that regard in the next versions in the future.
