IdeasGuy
patreon
Big Tipper Poll: Should I stick with the Waifu Catalog?
🕑 Added 2020-07-01 18:36:55 +0000 UTCI wanted to get some feedback on an idea I've been toying with. Basically, I'm thinking of not going with the waifu catalog and instead simply doing the occasional poll with waifus that would be voted on, much like Tifa was. I've been considering it for a bit now, but the waifu catalog isn't meant for the kind of story I'm trying to tell -- mainly, someone that's desperate to get a leg up on life and he's willing to walk over other people if he gets there.
The talents and defenses are just too broken and too cheap to not buy. Dragon Musk especially so. I've been trying to think of ways to either tweak my story or tweak the waifu catalog to make it fit what I want but I've just reached a point that I've realized it would just be simpler to not use it.
What would this mean? Like I said, other waifus would still appear. I'll list off a few -- probably something like two choices for Hero, Rogue, and Villain -- then you would vote and one would be picked. That aspect of the story wouldn't change much.
However, it would mean no Dragon Musk. Thus Vergil not being a dragon.
But an ironic saving grace -- Vergil has a far more dragon-like personality. He hoards wealth, he's more prideful and domineering, and he's ambitious. So, the reason I wrote the rewrite would be intact.
And, lastly, here's another factor -- I'm wanting to crosspost the clean version of this story to SB and SV. Simply put, the waifu catalog won't exactly go over well on those sites.
So, here are the choices:
Stick to the Waifu Catalog -- I go with pretty much the same build as I had before in Be a Dragon.
Don't stick with the Waifu Catalog -- There will be the occasional poll that decides a character to be included. Vergil is not a dragon and his power comes from a unique brand of magic.
Middle ground -- Vergil remains a dragon, but the Catalog is not used. The kind of dragon is undetermined at this point and would be decided by another poll. The choices would be something like a Dragonborn-like nature, or a Dragonslayer-ish transformation, etc.
And, to clarify, no matter what option is picked, I can work with. So pick what you would like to see.
Comments
Varisis
having powers is pretty boring and has been done before, being an actual dragon has not.
TinyDeath
I feel like the middle ground is the worst choice here. Either be a dragon, or don't...
Eldar Zecore
Exactly!
Antares
You could go the Fairy Tail or Skyrim route, the MC isn't a dragon but has elements of a Dragon, such as a dragons soul or their power is from a dragon etc.
Eldar Zecore
If anyone wants to argue or see my rant about this selection feel free to check out the other copy of this poll. I kinda ranted and want to know other’s opinions on it😅
