Post "Halloween Candy Draft // Regulation Draft" by "The Regulation Podcast" from patreon

Big T

Lil Spooky with the background stank

Mary Heppeard

Also, I HATE candy corn as well, I've never liked it; even as a child.

Mary Heppeard

Peanut Butter M&M is just Reese's Pieces & I don't like Peanut M&M's so I'd say that the bog standard M&M is the best

Dave

Insane. Reese's Pieces is far superior to any other similar candy.

Shawn Hilton

Eric Won

John L

Peanut Butter M&Ms are definitely superior to Reese's Pieces IMO. I think i'd have to pick a Whatchamacallit and a Zero bar and some Sixlets.

Kyle V

No we never did it like that. We kept them in the wrapper and rubbed them together real hard until a power started to come off the candy. Then we slightly opened one end and smoked the powder out

Cait Hicks

Has anyone ever smoked smarties before? Like crushed them all up and wrapped them back in their plastic and then put THAT in your mouth and blew it out like “smoke”?? My husband is claiming that this was a popular thing to do and it seems insane

Gabrielle Lewis

I’m not exactly sure who won but Andrew for sure lost with those last 2 picks. I love smarties and Crunch bars!

Gabrielle Lewis

Some people get King Size bars in trick or treating 🤷🏽‍♀️

KisaXIII

Also, no one said regular M&M, 3 musketeers, Milky Way (my favorite are the midnight), or regular Reese’s peanut butter cups, and that kinda surprises me too.

KisaXIII

I’m surprised no one said tootsie rolls for worst pick.

Arielle G

idk so torn between andrew and nick 😂😂

ListenTo100PercentEat

People like raisins Listen To 100% Eat

Aaron

Andrew had a win in the damn bag with those first two picks. I'm not mad, I'm just disappointed.

John Simpson

I feel like Geoff would like a PayDay

Zachafinackus

Candy Corn is goated

Joshua Kuhowski

No apples?

Keefin Bickmore

Eric wins first two picks are my favs. 100 grands are pretty good adding penut m&ms would have been the only addition to make it perfect

Collin Seymour

I think, for me, it’s a three way tie between Eric, Geoff, and Nick.

Collin Seymour

Andrew just straight up didn’t follow the rules. Definitely funny but, like, surely he can’t win. I mean half of his picks just are not candy at all

Brandon C

Andrew's last two picks were completely unhinged! There are some candies that come to mind that aren't exactly my favorite to get but are Halloween staples for me. The Marvel-themed candy sticks are one (commonly referred to as candy cigarettes), as well as Fun Dip (a rare find).

Kaitlin

Smarties are way better than m&ms. I live near the Canadian border and grab them every time I visit. That and coffee crisp

Kaitlin

Take five Snickers Kit Kat 3 musketeers are dog shit

Greg

cant agree with nick more on his smarties take

Gregory Curatola

We cannot allow Andrew to get away with this one! 😂

Suzi

Gavin had this in the bag!

ThrowBricksAtKids

Peanut chews #1 candy

The Elite Truth

ANDREW...IS...NOT...REAL lol.

Mookey

Wow, Eric and I have the exact favorites. Not sure how to feel about that....

Dustin

My friend James and I used to crush up smarties and snort them when we were in the 3rd grade!

Erica Lazarow

3 Musketeers not being on any list or even MENTIONED?! Criminal. Totally thought it was over with Nick’s first pick, but Eric’s draft takes the cake… or candy I guess

Isaac Orndorff

Andrew is something else man, ultimate wild card. “Oh what else would you want in your bag but $100,000!

Matthew Hughes

I agree with andrew I would be hyped to get that jar of peanut butter as a child. However as an adult if my kid got it I would be like unbeliveably suspicious of it because whoever gave that out was clearly a lunatic and I would like get that shit lab tested before letting my kid eat it for drugs or something. Or ya know it might have a razor blade because it is a whole ass jar of peanut butter XD.

LZ

Crack rock won it for Gavin, razor blade aint winning shit for Andrew lol

LZ

Smarties are terribe

LZ

Nick won. Candy corn and Smarties both suck… but Nick got the better Best candies.

WeeStev0

parma violets for the worst candy for sure

John Torres

I was with nick until the smarties slander

Anthony Bringas

How is the orange circus peanut not the worst candy to get?

Zee Villa

Andrew was winning until the entire jar of PB 🤣

iAmAlphaLegend

Almond joy, flavored mini tootsie rolls, skittles

Anthony George

Andrew disagreeing with Gavin picking crack in the not rocks draft bit putting a jar of peanut butter in this one is a real mood

Shwafta

Eric has to win this bc he picked the best candy (twix) and the worst candy (candy corn)

Mr hamburgler

Good job Eric, you earned this one, GG Andrew, keep it real buddy

MaplexSyrup

Hey remember when Gavin was the one who wasn’t sure how this draft worked?

Chrispy McAwesome

Nick and I have the same palette

Irish Dave

Thought the Bueno was a bad pick from gavin - they're awesome, but you're never getting that in your Halloween bag!!

Russell Richardson

At least he’s a consistent madman😂

Russell Richardson

He is the best lil Rat man

Hannah Dernier

I thought they were going to have the limitation their picks had to be something they either received or gave on Halloween

Brittany F

Andrew...you started so strong

Brian D.

I want to shout out milkyway midnights, I can’t find them in anything aside from the party packs.

Ashley Theodoran

Eric ran away with this one

kyle walz

I was locked in to vote Nick until he picked smarties.

Jessica_C

Andrew……..

KaptainGrumbles

It's like Eric is speaking my exact candy thoughts. I've never agreed with anyone more on anything.

Evan VanWormer

Andrew trick or treats just like Mac's family does Christmas. He goes into peoples homes and into their cupboards and pantries to find his treats, with the expectation that someone is doing it to his house as well.

Logan garland

I dont care who wins as long as andrew looses. No one is handing out jars of peanut butter

Illien

We were robbed of the li’l gurp

Benjamin Herbert Newman

Andrew really messed his list up on those last two picks.

Craig

The Reese’s Peanut Butter Sequence may be the hardest I’ve ever laughed listening to a podcast. Completely unhinged.

102pointOOPS

Andrew is a menace and he needs to be stopped.

Shumbawamba

And Crunch/Buncha Cruch as alternate? Amazing.

Shumbawamba

(Oh no he hates candy corn...... 😬) Still has my vote.

Shumbawamba

I told myself in my head that if anyone said 100 Grand bar they would get my vote. Eric just also happened to pick the 2 other best chocolate candies. So he super wins my vote.

Eric

Nick's the winner for me and Andrew definitely deserved the criticism he got in this one. Also, my #1 pick for Trick or Treat candy is a weird one, but let me say this first - As a kid, I didn't understand the prices of things, I just knew what I liked more, what tasted better, what I craved. There was one house that for at least a couple Halloweens gave out cans of soda, and to this day I still would rather have a can of soda over a candy bar, so can of soda is my #1 pick.

Kevin D.

That whole thing sent me, almost as good as the discussion over Andrew's third pick.

Jean-Claude Niue

Gavin’s choice is my choice with Eric coming in close 2nd.

John Barnes

Gotta love Gavin’s “oh, it’s *Halloween* candy…” shaking the morale of the group 😂

Orville Tootenbacher

Witches brew Kit Kats FTW…

Tom Cooney

I normally listen at 1.5x but this time I listened at 1x speed and everyone sound slightly drunk and tired.

Jacob Smelcer

Waiting for the poll

Natalie

Nick fumbled the win so hard with saying smarties suck

Halfwit Studios

i’m convinced andrew threw this draft because he’s tired of winning. razor blade is such a “crack rock” pick that it got me laughing my ass off.

Aven

Never had a 100 Grand or a Mr Goodbar but I know as a kid I hated raisins, candy corn was at least candy. Geoff Wins. I love Rockets (Smarties) and I like Turkish Delight, though maybe not in a haloween bag. Andrew wtf. Sour Patch Kids is a nice break after so much chocolate, Reese's Pieces is an easy trade item but a tub of peanut butter? And Razor Blade is a straight loss on this list. it is halloween CANDY draft my man. As a fellow rules arguer you should know this.

numbr87

Nick won, but more importantly, Andrew got last place

comment leaver.

Easy win for Eric. Andrew.....what the hell.

John Roach

I'm going with Geoff on this one. As a Canadian, I'm sad and confused how Andrew never had mini Coffee Crisps!

Marqujr

Did we just find the one food Nick won't eat?

Jenny Hite

Eric wins, but worst are Dum Dums!

Kevin Naber

Peanut butter is insane. Razor blades is brilliant.

AlanW

This is the first one I thought Eric won.

Will

andrew melting down after he thought he had a winner with peanut butter was glorious

Tony K

Bruh I'm scared. I have the exact same taste buds as Eric. Every single thing he said including the nestles, and bunch a crunch and not liking fruity stuff and how he's more of a chocolate fan. We are taste buds twins wtffff

Vivian Strader

Hard agree with Eric on the Reese's pieces, they just taste weird!

JVSakura

Andrew LOST this draft SO BAD……..😂

Shell Collingburn

I'm not even British but Gavin's picks were spot on. People have been sleeping on the Twirl

Eric

I would’ve had a peach ring on there or a Milky Way midnight

Tyler

I’m torn between Geoff and Eric for winner of this draft

Keer

Andrew's list is exactly why he got kicked off the judging website

Avlin Starfall

Insane that Andrew was making fun of Gavin at first for not understanding the draft (as we all were) and then goes on to not only not pick a fucking candy, but also not even something you get in your Halloween candy bag! It's insane. Then goes to choose razer blades for least favorite candy?! Again not a candy even if the legend is they are given in Halloween bags it's not the key word in the draft "candy". Geoff's worst pick also doesn't count as it's not candy but at least it's edible and something actually given out.

macca S

They spoke so much about kikat that I went out and brought one

Yamori

Choosing Nick for the best candy but Andrew for worst. I like smarties, raisins and candy corn and I never had a Turkish delight so Andrew wins in that front lol

Joe

This rules Eric won

NerdTronJJ

Honesty I'm havin trouble on this one because all the hated picks I love minus andrews but that jar of thing made his list go out the friggin window lol

Hunter Holloway

Gonna have to day Eric wins. Andrew’s first 2 picks are great. A jar of peanut butter is insane, but I once got a box of KD in my Halloween bag

Mark Noble

I was going to vote for Andrew, until he ruined it with a jar of peanut butter

Animelady501

Eric takes the cake!

Cindy

Nick is the winner!!!

gasbolina

sorry to all the peanut based picks but they could never come near the euphoria of a teaser

Connor Brazeau

Nick's list wins. Hands down.

Ruby Pile

Eric wins hands down he's nailed my ideal Halloween haul and has the correct worst candy 😇💜

Alex Watson

“I… I don’t… I’m just… I’m so… I don’t know what to do. I don’t know what to do. I don’t know what to do. I… What am I supposed to do? Whaddu I do? What do I do? What am I supposed to do? What is this?” - Eric “so little idea what to do” BadDoor 2024

Ian B.

Andrew’s last two pick are like picking Jake from State Farm in the nfl draft. And not the cool Jake from State Farm.

Aaron Simmons

Circus peanuts not being picked for worst is a crime. I once heard circus peanuts described as a being marshmallow that had been emotionally abused. If that isn't the most accurate description I don't know what is.

Rob Andbeans

I’ll be a comment leaver for the first time to say that Eric had the best list. but Andrew could have cooked if he didn’t fumble a whole jar of PB.

Jessee Juarez

Nick gets it

Steven Rydarowski

I think Andrew should have just gone Crack Rock on the last round.

jacob schultz

Andrew dnf'd out after a super solid start. That was wild.

SomethingWithaG

This is so tough. Eric and Nick are neck and neck. I’m leaning Nick because of the Reese’s pumpkin alone… by far the best candy. Smarties as worst is a wild pick though.

Mo0KiE

I dont know who won but andrew lost

Yakuzie

Eric won for me because i hate/allergic to peanuts 😆

Joakim XwIIcK Lundberg

Thanks for all the hard work on these videos/podcasts lads

Yves Belliveau

Where do we vote tho

Josh A.

A fucking jar of peanut butter 😂

Maddie

Eric I get headaches from Reese’s pieces wtf?

Tristan Huyett

Andrew’s logic of “I’ve never gotten a jar of peanut butter but it would be awesome if I did” is so funny because by that logic, his first pick should have been “a check for one million dollars”

Ben LaBorde

Yup, some of my co workers think I’m going insane because I listen at the office and I can’t hold it in sometimes!

Aaron Reed

Gavin wins! Hands down!

Eli Munson

Nearly hurting myself trying not to burst out laughing in the dead silence of the office, it’s becoming a mini game of my life being a regulation fan

megan mazerolle

me ready to pick Nick, then he said Rockets.....damn. Gotta be Eric then.

Trozzbozz

Andrew shit the bed, I was on board with his first two picks.. going with Eric for the Kit Kat, but honorable mention to the kinder bueno, one of my favorites as an adult, but wasn’t around when I was a kid.

tayycro

Despite the fact that I love candy corn I do think Eric has the best draft list by far

Rachel F

Nick lost because of the smarties. Also no Milky Way is wild.

LynkedLyd

I’ve lost all respect for Nick in this moment

LynkedLyd

Throwing away smarties is a felony

Bar One

Eric won this by far

Cole

Nick: Solid regulation picks, standard candies. Smarties is insane--Smarties are awesome. Must not be a sugar-based candy guy. Gavin: All fake candy what the hell are you even talking about. I've only heard of Kinder Bueno advertized on BBC shows. Eric: Solid 2nd place--Twix and KitKit are S tier. I am biased towards candy corn. I also love the McRib as far as gross once a year foods go. Geoff: 1st place. Most sensible picks. Most sensible worst candy. A true American. Andrew: Sour candy is mid. Reeses Pieces are goated. Razor blades and jar of peanut butter is funny but he threw for content. DQ'd.

Tim Lyen

I agree most with Nick but his most hated candy caused him to lose my vote. Eric wins

Felipe Arcos

Andrew had such a good list going and then fucking imploded for no reason. lmaooo I loved this draft.

Robert Lacey

No love for milky way or 3 musketeers minis? At least Eric picked Twix, and KitKat is good, but i love candy corn. Gavin's picks look good but I've never had any. Overall I think everyone loses. (Gavin probably wins because those at least sound like I'd agree).

David Mead

Eric nailed it.

Exit8Jake

Geoff was definitely just going to pick every size of Snickers bar to begin with. (Fun size, mini, full size, king size)

The Okapi

Geoff won, no contest

DL2729

I’m disappointed none of the guys broke the news to Andrew that the tubs of Reese’s peanut butter isn’t the same as the candy peanut butter inside the cups and pieces. It’s just peanut butter.

Sean Lunt

I spoke moments too soon. Nick wins for picking rockets as the worst. Still sour Andrew snubbed smarties for a jar of shit peanut butter though

Sean Lunt

Andrew disappointing to snub two Canadian easy picks. Tail end but in yhe 'best' list, smarties (Canadian, basically much better m&ms). Worst, rockets (the us version of smarties, gross packed sugar pucks)

Andrew Montana

Gavin absolutely killed it.

ArtsyStarky

I honestly can’t tell sometimes if Andrew is trolling or not. 😭

Bodge

Turkish delight is amazing

Toby Ives-Moody

This might be brit bias, but Gavin wins hands-down

Eric Jones

Nick absolutely killed it.

Will H.

Geoff wins for me. Eric had me except the 100 grand pick. Unmentioned pick for worst- absolutely no contest it goes to the little 3 packs of whoppers. I'd truly rather have the raisins.

Patrick Kelly

Second favorite m&m is the holiday sugar cookie one

Glitchytextures

If a best candy is a king size bar they win immediately

Chimp Steinham

Chill out man, it’s five grown men talking about candy

ryan mehan

This is going to be hard for me to pick a winner. I'm allergic to any nut so I haven't had most of these

Chimp Steinham

Garage doors are expensive and that’s vandalism, Terrence.

Tom Herondale

Thank you Eric, I'm so glad I'm not the only one who thinks candy corn are absolute goddamn garbage!

Jack Draper

Eric or Gavin for me win, Andrew is a psychopath

Kyle V

Geoff is the definition of a true American classic. He's like an old Harley. Geoff is baseball. Geoff wins

imnotthatbrad

Nick unlocked a core memory with Butterfinger BB’s, wow. I fucking loved those

Eric Taylor

Toss up between Eric and Geoff. But I would rather have candy corn over raisins so going with Geoff

Chaz Surfboard

I surely thought Nick was going with Necco Wafers and I'm shocked where he went

Dustin

Gotta remember to leave my peanut butter out for the Great Pumpkin this year.

Chaz Surfboard

If Andrew gets this one...what a final pick

Dustin

Nah nah nah, it’s Halloween candy, don’t buy it for the taste test. Trick-or-treat for it!

Joshua Smith

Snickers or Mars for me

KVLT

How did Eric work a D into 'innit'?

javonyo

so clearly geoff here

Soots

I think either Gavin's pick won because all those British chocolates are top tier, or Eric's cause it's the closest to my taste from childhood. My personal list without repeating from the draft would be: • Hershey's - any kind, i know gavin hates it and not the best quality chocolate but my taste buds didn't give a shit, I'd go nuts when I got some in my bag as a kid • Milky Way - next best thing to a Twix, caramel bliss, a classic 👌 • Jolly Rancher - some of the most potent candy, addicting, every flavor was fire • Worst thing to get in your Halloween bag..... fucking Tootsie Rolls. Like what the fuck is it, it's brown but not chocolate, it's chewy but not candy, get that shit outta here 😤 and tootsie pops were such a Trojan horse 😒

Ryan4pie

Bernnotice likes Milhouse

Tori Marx

Gav absolutely won that one.

Offbeat Creates

Andrew made me lose it. Cackling in the wee hours of the morning for such an insane take xD

Jeff Freeman

I’ve always wanted them to do 5 picks

Jeff Freeman

Take 5 is like all the best things you can have in a candy bar put together. One of my favs for sure

Jeff Freeman

Yeah he had my vote until the end there

Jeff Freeman

They are really good. It’s like a thick chewy caramel nougat with a layer of kripsy’s on top and covered in chocolate.

Jacob Collier

Eric went nearly perfect on his list. I'd just trade 100 Grand for the Crunch bar.

Jeff Freeman

Yes! I don’t even understand what the point of good and plenty was.

Pandabations

i though andrew was going to pick the peanut inside of the peanut m&m's also andrew cant win that is my vote

Anthony Dewitt

Gavin or Eric for me, although there was quite a few candy’s I’ve never had nor heard of

Kobe Fellows

Ya know I deliver that tub of Reese's Peanut Butter now and then to some places, and I'll say, Andrew is freaking insane to think that's a real pick 😭🤣 I've also tried that stuff and it ain't good 👍 wouldn't recommend

Jaimie Allmond

Worst-Good and plenty.

laul

the plot twist of thinking gavin didn’t understand the draft theme to andrew completely salad creaming it ..

Chris Anderson

I see what you're doing Andrew, I see what you're doing. I tip my hat to you

nick hemley

Dead heat between Gavin and Eric here. Not a fan of Blow Pops but like the rest of Geoff's picks so he's a close third. I hate peanut butter & chocolate products, so Nick is 4th, and Andrew? There are no words for this monstrosity of a draft. DSQ for him

EnragedPanda6

Andrew are you okay?

Darth-Jasonus

Gonna have to go with Gav on this one, with Eric being a close second. (that said, never heard of a 100 grand bar)

Nathaniel Borgen

Karl Pilkington said "you never seen an old man eat a Twix" but then you see Eric draft it first

Thindler's Lisp

I was waiting the whole draft for him to pick it because it's absolutely something Eric would hate lol. Candy corn is so good (BRANCH'S!!! Do NOT get Zachary's!!)

Thindler's Lisp

Geoff wins. It was between him and Nick for me, but Geoff nailed the worst candy. Little box of raisins is the PERFECT bad candy.

Daniel McGrotty

“That’s the great thing about a jar of peanut butter. You can see if the seal has been tampered”. Has Andrew been getting candy that wasn’t sealed in wrapping his whole life?

EnragedPanda6

❤️

Thindler's Lisp

Insane that I agree with Eric on Reese's pieces yet disagree on everything else. Candy Corn and Skittles would be at the top of my list!

Jane-Anne Maple

I can't believe no one picked Mary James for the worst candy

BernNotice

Came for the laughs, stayed for the Milhouse lore

Assleg

I’m torn between Eric and Gavin on this one

Dave Pratt

I was absolutely on Andrew's side... until round 3. Gotta go with Gavin on this one.

Robert Collins

The lack of Tootsie Pops was disappointing.

Weeble

Gavin's "Nestle Milhouse" was criminally underappreciated.

fundued games

why did no one pick curcuis penuts as the worst candy

Summer

circus peanuts are delicious

Lui

Nick really threw on the last Smarties pick, thats crazy

Lemur Wetsuit

I appreciate the upgrade in your draft setup. But honestly I am going to miss the janky exel spreadsheet setup from before.

Julian Connell

A frozen Mr. Goodbar is so good. It's basically just having the coating part of a Drumstick Ice Cream.

numbr87

Probably the 100% Eat studio

numbr87

They spent so long clarifying it had to be stuff you get in a Halloween bag, and Andrew went with a jar and thought he was a genius? Someone check the CO2 in his place.

Vater

Eric said to Nick around 17:00 “Don’t worry, I got some at the studio for us”. What studio? I thought Andrew nixed the studio…

Dan Walsh

aw man, I wish they could have gotten Graysie for this one, her anti-chocolate stance would've been fun

Dan Walsh

I'm glad Eric mentioned Crunch Bars at the end there, I love those, but also Take 5, those things are amazing!

Dan Walsh

I really loved candy corn as a kid then it was one of those things a switch flipped and I never want it again

Dan Walsh

Andrew's final best pick is absurd and such an Andrew move. Also I gotta say Geoff is the winner of this one

Ronai Schafer

Caramel apple sucker needed to be up there!

chris courtney

Gavin easily, Eric a good runner up

Joshua Neditch

Eric wins hands down

Geoff Sierra-George

Is peanut buttering it the new salad creaming it

nd4spd1919

Gotta go with Eric here; Andrew lost me in the second half, and Nick had the insane Smarties take, and I can't support anything related to that.

Sean Kathrein

Man Andrew had me for the first half of his pick, but holy crap the last half haha. Gotta go with Eric's picks!

DudeRetro

Another great draft by the regulation crew. Andrew is a crazy person. You are all the best

Junkchan

I'm shocked nobody said Dots for the worst candy

Dan Walsh

loving this new visual format!

Ian Morrison

might be the hardest draft to relate to for me since i was allergic to peanut butter and peanuts my whole childhood so i haven't had half of these things and everything on nicks "team" is revolting to me

Abbie

Do we think Gavin has smartie trauma from blending them up and putting them on Trevor’s desk

Brian

Best: laffy taffy (specifically banana) Worst: milk duds (too hard)

Kanan Sloanjah

also eric wins

Kanan Sloanjah

Andrew is a lunatic

Kyle

Nick saying smarties are bad is unreal

Casey C

Eric wins

Super Daddy Kyle

Feedback: Drafts should be 5 picks each, there is 5 of you, makes 5×5 looks good, it shows everyone's top 5. It just makes sense.

アダム

Nicks list was amazing until he put Smarties as his hated candy.

Super Daddy Kyle

Without fail every draft someone doesn't understand the draft (probably Gavin, maybe Andrew) and it's funny every time.

B

I’m surprised they let him keep that jar pick. What’s the point of clearly defining the rules, and saying candy you’d get on Halloween?

Josh A.

“SPOoKY!” -Gavin Free (2024)

vibin_psilocybin

Thank you, Andrew, for being so willing to sacrifice yourself in the name of content. He had to have known that everyone would blow up and make the funny.

Summer

and can you believe they’re actually called peanut butter kisses? 🤮

Summer

right????? shameful

Trevor Deal

I knew someone was going to pick Candy Corn as the worst and piss me off and of course it was Eric lol. I like Smarties but I understand why people wouldn't like them but Candy Corn is a hyperbolic choice just because of its popularity. How the hell did no one say Circus Peanuts which isn't even candy. It's a practical joke that won't go away. It's the literal worse candy on the planet. Wax Cola Bottles, Good & Plenty? COME ON.

Psilocvbin

Before I even click play, without knowing how to actually draft, I’d choose… Butter finger Snickers Any unguarded bowl And Jell-O shots for the adults Edit: candy corn for the worst

RegulationGraham

The worst Halloween candy is actually a rock à la Charlie Brown

The_RyBar

No crunchbar nor Reese's cup. No one wins. Except nick Never mind. Smarties are amazing and pumpkin corns are amazing

Wolf

I think Nick wins this one, while I like smarties and candy corn, both of them I have a tolerance for. The biggest loser of this draft should be Andrew though and they always give Gavin crap for not understanding the rules when Andrew pulls this.

Vanth

Was with Andrew till his #1 lol that was seriously wild

Michael M

Gavins just like me innit

Jeremy Hixon

Also, Nick, Smarties...WTF?!

Dr5hark

Eric

Jeremy Hixon

You could dip your handful of Percocet in it.

Stryix

Gavin's"No Shit" wins the draft street Andrew's last round fuggin' punt. What an absolute punt.

Rob

Eric 100% wins this

Saun Tonkin-McAtee

Gavin wins easily

Rage Fueled

I think so. I had the same thought.

Rage Fueled

“Yeah, can I change my final pick to handful of Percocet?” Best line in the whole damn thing. Hahahahaha

Kayla Lesperance

Gavin ftw xo

Thorne17

Andrew really thought he cooked with that jar of peanut butter lol. Gotta say though, really elevated this draft for me, easily one of the best drafts you guys have done.

NoThatOtherGuy

Nobody said black licorice for the worst?

Chad Jorgenson

I can't believe no one took the best halloween candy that you find in your bag at the end of the night, a thousand dollars. Who wouldn't be excited at the end of the night to find a literal bundle of cash in their HALLOWEEN candy bag. Right Andrew??

Mr. Dingdong

Gotta give the win to Eric especially for the 100 Grand pick.Surprised there was no Charleston Chew in anyone's worst Halloween Candy.

JivetheSuperTurkey

Eric almost begging "what do I do?" is the realest shit in the world lmao

Owen

SO GLAD to see 100 Grand make the list!!! Its is my ABSOLUTE favorite but no ones ever had one so to see it get represented makes my day!! Love that Eric agrees

Dirk Bogan

Gavin wins purely based on the Twirl pick. Such an underrated pick.

Kin-Ho Ma

Guessed Gavin said code Turkish Delight as the worst

MaidOfCake

Eric got this one

Communist bigfoot

I knew this was gonna be good when the table was 3/4 full and the video was only half done. This was beautiful

Chris Courtney

Eric cleared, would love to know what the guy’s favorite Halloween costumes they’ve wore as kids

Adam Staron

Eric picked what I would have picked for my top 3. What a win.

Bryce Thronson

Eric won this one for sure.

Jeremy B

Geoff Won

WhoMikeYork

I almost wrecked my car because I was laughing so hard at the jar of peanut butter talk

Beastacome

The Turkish Delight slander is foul

ThatoneGuyoverThere33

is a Kit Kat Chunky the same as a Big Kat?

Helepolis

For lack of experience with Gavins candy I going to have to give it to Geoff. I was on board for Nick and Eric picks untill they got to their last one. Andrew did alright for him, but his last 2 picks were unsurprisingly insane.

taukid

The first time they used the generator, that's when they try to change up the number, smh

Austin Kear

Andrew flopped

LawlessReaper

In my opinion nobody won but Andrew definitely lost.

Joey King

worst candy to get are DOTS. always hated those things

ma.reindeer

Gavin won as soon as he said "Kinder"

Eoin

Seen that "+Graysie" button and got excited for a second.

MaplexSyrup

I haven’t gotten to the end yet, but if Andrew can do his own bit during the states draft that Gavin should not be over complicating it lol

Willsy

Gavin wins but should have had bounty in p4. UK babyyy

Skylavich

Nick had it until the Smarties pick... The worst candy is Dubble Bubble. Hard as rocks...

Willsy

Honestly, salad cream would have made more sense than either of Andrew's last 2 picks

Emma Massey

Twirl is my favorite candy ever and I’m not even British

Terrance

One house gave out potatoes. We threw them at their garage door

Sablever

This list is crazy. I only like 5 of the candies up top but I love smarties and candy corn. Raisins aren't even candy, but I kind of have to vote Geoff as the winner.

Rice Chan

Geoff picked a solid list IMO. I'm going to go a British import store to try Gavin's list though. That may sway my vote.. we'll see!

Eduardo Lopez

I loved the raisins as a kid and everyone that hated them would give them to me and i would have so many raisins. I was a happy kid!

DancingBear

Johnny Caviar showed up in the back half for Andrew. Lmao

nyahlathotep

I really like adding a worst row at the end

Alan Reynolds

I think I like Eric's list the best, I like a 100 grand once in awhile but they take forever to eat because the caramel is so chewy, and I love candy corn (I know he picked it as worst but all his other picks are great). Reese's pieces is definitely my favorite pick but the jar of Reese's PB is a crazy pick. I think my favorite that's not on the list is specifically the orange halloween Kit-kat which I believed they stopped selling a year or two ago, used to get at least a couple bags every Halloween.

Paigella

Same - I adore Mr Goodbars but ONLY for halloween and only the little ones - he's so right

Ardvark Man

I love how pedantic Andrew gets about setting the rules, just to completely ignore them 😂

Lurty

I got a warm can of brisk ice tea while trick or treating once.

DumGun

Does anyone get creepy vibes from the packaging of the Cadbury Twirl? Like the the image of the inside of the candy is weirding me out…

kazmeyer

How did nobody pick those horrible, rock-hard black and orange peanut butter lumps for worst candy? I'd honestly take a razor blade over those.

Ryan Pattison

Was torn between Nick and Eric until the last round. The smarties pick by Nick sealed the deal for Eric. I am intrigued by and appreciate Gavin's list as well.

Adam Watson

Gavin wiped the floor with everyone else

Chris Buckley

Nick, you’re wrong on that worst pick

Chris Buckley

Absolutely love the candy corn pumpkins

Chris Buckley

Also Andrew you missed on not picking Coffee Crisp

Chris Buckley

The razor blade was a myth Andrew

Zombie Dave

Razor blades & PB is ridiculous and should be disqualified. That’s like picking a winning lottery ticket, as a valid best option. Also, if Jar of PB was such a great better than everything because it can enhance everything pick than why save it for last. Andrew thought he was pulling a fast one, but it reality he just blew the assignment - due to not fully understanding the hidden underwriting of the task. You can’t go into a halloween candy draft and drop completely unrealistic options to try to swing the vote. While you’re at it go back to the drinks draft and pick a swig from the fountain of youth.

Chris Buckley

.webp is the worst thing ever introduced to google images

AceOXAT

I don't know if I've seen a fumble that bad since the Falcons lost the Super Bowl to the Patriots. Andrew had a solid first half. This has to be a long term bit or something.

Yo Mama

Worst thing I received as a kid was a quarter. What the fuck am I supposed to do with money?

Aidan Dressler

Hell of an intro

UnklDnkl

Nick had my vote until the last second. I can't support this smarties slander.

Summer

candy corn, not good. candy corn pumpkins, delicious. I’ve literally made myself sick on smarties and I could still demolish a bag. the best part is getting them to dissolve in your mouth 🤤 I’m sad no one took fun-dip. or whatchamacallit. I’m also partial to krackel, whoppers, and wax fangs. also no one got the worst candy right: peanut butter taffy in the unmarked orange and black wrappers.

Benjamin Garner

Geoff nailed it for me.

Summer

$7? try $16 lol

Hector Sanchez

Eric won it for me on the candy corn pick. Bad candy

Kng Sht

The autism from Andrew really shows in this episode.

CloudyVro

I lost myself laughing out loud when Eric had his. What am I supposed to do moment?

Mick 16

How did andrew overlook candycorn? Its like stereotypical bad halloween candy

CheapCulture

I’ve only ever seen that Michael Jackson/E.T. pic in the “Alien vs Predator” context

Capt137

Also, worst candy is Good & Plenty. Candy-coated black licorice was such a nasty surprise

Mick 16

Andrew grandiose announcement of his own demise was so beast

Oliver Record

Eric won this one. I do really appreciate Gavin's picks, especially Turkish Delight. There's not a candy in the world I'd rather have to eat less than a Turkish fucking delight.

Jesse Bryant

Eric SWEPT this draft. What a masterful list. You sir are a man of high culture and deserve only the best this Halloween season.

Kayla

Wow, Eric NAILED this one for me, our candy preferences line up exactly

Capt137

How does Andrew's keyboard not have its own colony of ANTS?!

Gam3r009

they make mini jars of nutella for easter, christmas, im not sure if they make it for halloween but if they dont they need to. so andrew isnt too far off this his peanut butter choice.

Archer

I don't care if it's reese's peanut butter, I'd be pissed as a kid if someone gave me a jar of peanut butter.

Sean Place

Eric cooked here

Zach Anaya

Nick won for me. Smarties got him the win over Candy Corn for Eric

James Scott

I started this thinking I was going to be mad at Gavin but ended up shocked it was andrew.

Rebekah

Someone pls check in on Andrew what the actual fuck 😂 Nick had me until he picked smarties as the worst.

Kole

Nick is hands down the champion

Dr Pompidou

'You'd love it if you got a jar of peanut butter in your bag' yeah, I'd also love it if someone dropped in thirty grand in cash, it doesn't make it a halloween candy

Carson Thorn

andrew what the hell LMAO

ViciousWarGoose

Andrew lost this so hard

David Gentilcore

Overall I have to give it to Eric. Blow pops are great though.

Pokara

Geoff wins with Blow Pop

Seth Heder

Eric swept. I told myself whoever got 100 Grand in the back half of the draft would have my vote. Not only did he get the 100 grand but he also got Twix and KitKat. MONSTER draft from the big dawg

Michael Burhouse

Was fine for me

cyanann

I know eric is hella cali mex-am but he needs to stand up for mexican candies, there's so many good ones

Flyingwhale

You should make Andrew give out jars of peanut butter for Halloween and see how that works out

Brendon Davis

Nick had this locked up until he said smarties are bad. Eric wins after that choker pick

Megan

Andrew "did research" but did not know that the razors were not real and forgot about candy corn. What did he research?

Moosifer

We got so close to the end of this draft before Andrew decided to throw a wrench into everything with his 4th pick.

Megan

Andrew fucked up, thats not candy. He should be disqualifed

Boone Bass

Eric won this for me

Norm

Oh Andrew… you done fucked up so bad.

HeraldicMage

Between the 100 Grand and the Candy Corn, Eric has my vote on this draft. Though I would say that candy corn is definitely worse than razor blades. Razor blades at least have a use.

Michael

after andrews last pick im not convinced he has ever been trick or treating

Spoon

My mom also checked my candy for razor blades but only to pick out the candy she wanted…

shutts

Eric wins. 100 grand is one of those candy bars that I would never buy a full size of, but can't get enough of when it comes to halloween fun size

cdraughan

The razor blade joke would’ve landed so much better if he hadn’t ruined it with the jar of peanut butter lmfao

ah_cormac

Oh I didn’t realise a fan created this, I typed that first comment within like 10 seconds! I apologise 🤣 that’s actually super cool

Emily Burnside

The way Eric won this one and it isn't even close

ah_cormac

Bring back random.com!!! Going since 1998 show it some love

Jytole

Audio seemed fine for me on mobile

Tim Harris

Geoff won, easy

shutts

Was the audio kinda fucked up in this one? It could have been my set up casting to my tv

dingdong45

A 100 grand bar ripped one of my teeth out as a kid and I've been scared of them since

Jimmy Taveras

I did not expect to be thinking about work watching this. I work at the Hershey plant that made the KitKat snack size they used. Ca-Cawww

Thomas Johnson

Razor blades are gross but they aren't Smarties at least

Josh Burr

What the hell Andrew. 🤣 He was so confident what a terrible pick. 🤦🏼‍♂️

Ezrah

Ditto with the kinder bar. If you get the little 2 bites. Perfection

Anthony Caldwell

...I mean, what did we really expect from Andrew?

Taylor Wilson

I think razor blade was soooo good, but I don't know if it overpowers the insanity of a JAR of peanut butter.

Taylor Hickey

The way Andrew says “okay” at 34:13 is so damn funny to me lol

Taylor Hickey

I was with him till the smarties slande

Taylor Hickey

I couldn’t tell who said it at the beginning and was floored when they said Gavin lol

Ryan Rabideau

Nick won it for me just for picking Reese Pumpkin. Also Andrew what the fuck?

terry thorpe

Wow Eric loves British chocolate bars, he pick the same amount of British stuff as Gavin.

Kyle Potter

Safe to say Andrew lost🤣

Ashe

Andrew, I love you and normally I'm on your side. But you're an idiot, eat the pencil

Justice Rainz

Eric putting candy corn as his worst made him my pick

Mitchell Goodwin

Do I have to still vote for Nick despite that Smarties slander? I really was thinking “Nick has this on lock save for a horrendous last pick” and then he said that