Horror Movie Bundle Draft
🕑 Added 2024-10-28 14:00:11 +0000 UTCWho won?
Comments
Crohnenberg
The lack of Geoff love is apparent. Def #1 for me
Aidan Devlon
I thought Eric blew everyone out of the water, then Gavin, and then I wasn’t sure. I see the vote percents match, nice.
Joe
Which one did Nick vote for?
Madi
I chose Andrew because I love Bone Tomahawk too
Libby Goldstein
Eric smoked this one, insane draft
Matt
This was a very hard one. Andrew almost ruined it right off the bat, but he won me back in the end. Eric was a VERY close second.
Robert Trimble
Zombies are ruined for me. the early-mid 2000s was littered with zombies. movies, tv shows, games... too played out.
Anthony Dewitt
Best selection was Nick, but best bargain bin grab was Gavin. Because really one would want to buy either a combo of good and new to you horror or a set which had a whole collection of interesting sounding horror.
Floffen
Thank you! Fixed it
Tyler Putnam
I'm a sucker for zombie movies...and Cloverfield I guess?
Furitaurus
I think my favourite line up was Gavin's, purely because his line up didn't contain a film I *hate* (Blair witch project and Cloverfield because they're found footage movies, Scream because I just hate that whole fucking franchise) or contained too many films I haven't seen, (sorry Geoff, I've only seen the Evil Dead 1&2 on your list, fucking awesome though they are).
Kat don Vee
It's a tough call between Nick and Geoff for me. I think they executed the theme of their sets the best. I think I'm gonna have to give it to Geoff for creativity, though.
Kat don Vee
Definitely horror to Geoff, hater of snakes lol
Amy Bowman
Are the actual lists shown somewhere? I always forget them by the time I come to vote.
Ruby Valentine
Nick has the best list!!!! lol coming from a avid horror buff lol
Tim Lyen
I appreciate Gavin's theme but Eric has the overall best box set
Chimp Steinham
Nah just go off the vibes that are still in your system the next day. Vote with your heart
Chimp Steinham
Iran is the Michigan of the Middle East
Conrad500
Gavin's movies are better, and he has a great theme!
Laurie Arnold
Best list to worst in my opinion goes: Eric > Gavin > Geoff > Nick > Andrew
Kracka
Is Anaconda a horror movie?
Berenice Robledo
I’m gonna be honest Andrew lost me the moment he chose Anaconda
LZ
Funny jow Gavin suggested this… Gav must have had it open…
Dhuvy
The Rat Man, by far!
Benjamin Oliverio
Eric by a mile.
brikbeans
IMDB SCORES Andrew: 4.9 + 8.2 + 7.1 + 8.1 + 7.4 = 35.7 Gavin: 8.4 + 7.2 + 6.7 + 8.1 + 8.5 = 38.9 Geoff: 6.8 + 7 + 7.7 + 7.4 + 6.9 = 35.8 Nick: 7 + 7.6 + 7.5 + 7.8 + 7.4 = 37.3 Eric: 6.5 + 7 + 7.4 + 8.5 + 8.4 = 37.8 All out of 50 ofc (i didnt double check which dawn of the dead Nick ment so i used the original other one is 7.2)
Ben Delahay
Same. Gotta respect the Zombie fan (and Cloverfield)
Tom
Never would’ve thought I’d be voting for Eric two drafts in a row, but here we are. Looks like he’s won both, too.
93.5 Friendship Station
Gavin wins by default for having a Cronenberg movie
Saun Tonkin-McAtee
It was between Nick, Gavin and Eric for me. I chose Nick because he was the underdog.
Dan O
Nick close second but I’ve picked enough dvd packs out of the bin to know Eric is the real winner
Griffin Berwick
I am torn for this draft Nick has 2 of my favorite movies but Erics choices make it a stellar movie pack; and because of the theme of making it a movie pack I have to vote for the Rat.
RegulationKiwi
Nope, no slashers no dice. Andrew has the least, so Andrew gets a vote.
Aven
Andrew: -2, +3, +1, +3, -2 (Never seen Bone Tomahawk but I'm interested in giving it a go) Gavin: +3, +1, +1, +1, -1 Geoff: +1, +1, +3, +1, 0 (Never seen Barbarian; Left for Dead 1 never really hit home with me; no interest in A Girl walks home at night) Nick: +1, +2, +3, +1, +1 (Cloverfield is dumb but fun, 28 Days Later was if not genre defining then at least genre modernizing, Dawn of the Dead is dumb but fun and never seen [REC]) Eric: 0, +2, +1, +2, +/-3 (Blair witch didnt do it for me, havn't seen Jacobs Ladder in ages and should probably watch it again, The Shining was an amazing book and much of the movie was great too, but I really didn't like Jack Nicholson's, Shelly Duvall's, or Danny Lloyd's performances. Nicholson was great at being crazy but I couldn't buy him as sane.) All in all, Nick wins.
Bevschwa
Geoff was cheated out of Scream because of Andrew’s mistake on “It Follows”, so that might give you something to think about… I chose Geoff
Bevschwa
AND andrew cheated him out of Scream because he took too many points away for “It Follows” so if that validates your pick anymore, there ya go :)
Sean Place
A Girl Walks Home Alone at Night, while not enough to overcome Eric’s bangers, is an awesome movie. Geoff pitching his studio by saying they’ll remake it for American audiences is not exactly a recipe for success, though
Jacob Smelcer
Not a horror guy, Jaw is the only movie I've seen on this list (not really sure that's a horror movie, but okay). Gav get my vote.
ArtsyStarky
Eric crushed this one. This rules.
Alex Meyer
I was between Geoff and Eric for this one
Jason Campbell
The Thing is right up there as my favorite horror movie, but the "isolation" idea is perfect for me.
Rachel Dickey
I am a sucker for zombie films so of course I had to go with Nick lol
Sydney Blumel
So valid. I really went back and forth between Eric and Nick for a while because of it too.
B
Gavin’s last movie is Psycho, not Scream
robotabo
I had the same thought but came to the conclusion I had to choose Gavin because of how much I hated Blair Witch
Sydney Blumel
Hate to say it because I despise the Blair witch project but every other movie Eric picked is an absolute banger so I have to pick him >.<
Wilson Martino
Gavin simply because I could watch Jaws 100x in a row, then finally see Aliens for the first time
Courtney Langstrom
Yeah I think Eric has a solid watch party playlist of movies, but to me Nick has the movies that feel more good horror movie themed
LZ
Lord know nobody else will…
Cindy
For me, Eric wins simply for The Cabin in the Woods.
Tony Queen
Eric is the only one who went in with any decent strategy. No contest for me
The Antelope Fishermen
Michigan boys voting for Geoff as quick as possible
Bryan Yates
Eric nailed it so well I had to log in and vote/comment. Although, I'd have bought any of these box sets if I saw them in Hastings' bargain bin
Psilocvbin
I’ve seen the most on Eric’s list. I wish I’d seen them all to really give a good score
Lori Lindo
I actually liked everyones box set , even the randomness of Gavin and Andrew but Eric's low budget production company hit the mark. China knows America best 😄.
Nathan Hancey
Doing their job for them tbh
GolinSoul
we really need to start adding either the items or an image of what everyone has on these poll posts cuz i can never remember lul
bwp108
Eric and Nick had great choices, but 2 Evil Dead films I have to vote for Geoff.
Bennu
From the company name, to the solid choices, to that one reddit post of what the boxart could look like... Eric has this free.
CrystalOnyx
Agreed it doesn't take that much time (I do vote from mobile). It's just a convince thing for the users. I do get the argument of spoilers though. Maybe a large break and then a spoiler warning
Michael Mariani
I believe Eric has it
Kyle Potter
Gotta give it to Nick For scream movie has a special place in my heart atm
Brandon Berry
Even though he didnt want it. Nick with Cloverfield off the rip is a great pic for me. Then he caps it off with REC.!! Thats a winner all day for me.
Trevor Deal
Scroll down one post, press play and fast forward. Maybe that's more annoying on the phone but on desktop it takes 5 seconds.
Trevor Deal
Everyone has some greats but Nick's theme is the most interesting to me and a more fun watch. Some of the classics are great but no interest in watching The Exorcist again or The Ring. A zombie movie is a much more chill experience.
_Sebward
Ignoring that he insulted me pretty heavily at the beginning, Eric has my vote!
Tilgare
Early lead for Eric! Could be his first win! 🤞
CrystalOnyx
Hey on these in the future can we get a summary of the picks? I can never remember the exact list when I see these polls popup and have to go back to the end of the video
Chriztian
What would your picks be for their 5 movie collection and theme be? Using picks that they chose or other movies listed on the IMDb top 100. Mine would be Dead Silence, Insidious, Paranormal Activity, The Ring, and The Exorcist. Theme is movies involving Ghosts or Possessed Spirits
ComradeCrazylegs
Absolute Best Film Studio Winner
Sean Larmee
As a lifelong Michigander I have to support Geoff’s vision.
Splendy, The Tire God
No matter who wins I have a list of 25 horror movies that I want to watch.
Kyle B
I’m Irish but worked in Michigan for a few years, Geoff therefore gets my vote!
Floffen
Andrew: Anaconda, The Thing, Bone Tomahawk, The Exorcist, Scream. Gavin: Aliens, Ringu, Scanners, Jaws, Psycho. Geoff: It Follows, Barbarian, Evil Dead 2, The Evil Dead, A Girl Walks Home Alone At Night. Nick: Cloverfield, Train to Busan, 28 Days Later, Dawn of the Dead, [REC]. Eric: The Blair Witch Project, The Cabin in the Woods, Jacob's Ladder, Alien, The Shining.
Andrew Wells
Doing the Lords work 🙏
Colin Curtis
Andrew: Anaconda, The Thing, Bone Tomahawk, The Exorcist, Scream Gavin: Aliens, Ringu, Scanners, Jaws, Psycho Geoff: It Follows, Barbarian, Evil Dead 2, The Evil Dead, A Girl Walks Home Alone at Night Nick: Cloverfield, Train to Busan, 28 Days Later, Dawn of the Dead, [REC] Eric: The Blair Witch Project, The Cabin in the Woods, Jacob's Ladder, Alien, The Shining
Killroy Jenkins
This is actually such a close one. Eric probably has the best overall though.
Killroy Jenkins
Yeah like a screenshot of the final picks would help. Just because it's 5 people's list of 5.
Matthew Hughes
I have not watched the full episode yet, but I am voting Eric because A I am not a big horror movie person so not super qualified for this one and B I wanna see where the narrative of this stuido name thing goes if he wins.
Sir Fishy
I don't know enough horror movies to truly vote, Geoff was cheated so he gets my vote
Kat
Is there a way that y’all could include the final picks of the draft in the voting post? This post usually comes out after the episode- a day or so after lots have listened to it- so personally I forget and have to go back to the end of the video to remember who did what. Anyways, no worries if it’s just a “me” thing lol but maybe it’d be helpful for others too? :)
Bevschwa
Andrew cheated Geoff out of Scream by taking 47 points for It Follows instead of the 30 he should have, so Geoff gets my vote because his original list with Scream would have been my pick.
Avlin Starfall
Have to go with Nick for 1 but Eric was so close. I just don't care for Blair Witch, that's the only thing knocking it down one.
Chaz Surfboard
It's my (rat)man Eric
Tamir Tuvel
This might be the closest poll in regard to who to pick. Everyone has a very solid line up.
Ashley
Gavin’s list was shockingly good considering how he went about the whole thing lol. Eric was definitely the winner here though
Archery Contest
Gavin's theme is strongest and has a variety of horror genres/vibes
Zach Houston
Eric just picked absolute banger after absolute banger.
Egan
Nick drafted Rec, my favourite horror film so I have to go there. Also if you watch Rec, make sure you watch Rec 2 also which takes place 30 seconds after Rec.
David Mead
One word bangers is the best
Ryan W March
Eric no question here it's just a solid list
Chance Multhoff
Me personally I absolutely loved nicks, but instead of REC I would have gone with Quarantine but still 11/10 bundle
Alonzo Mendez
Eric got the dub for me
ryan mehan
Andrew with the 1 % is funny to me
Zachafinackus
Can't believe no one fought Gav for Ringu.