Draft Poll
🕑 Added 2024-12-02 17:00:15 +0000 UTCWho won the dog and cream draft?
Comments
Mr. Dude Sky
Gotta vote in solidarity with chocolate ice cream
Mara Copland
Man. If Andrew had picked a poutine dog, he would’ve had it. I want one so bad.
Mr. Dingdong
Voting Gavin as more of a protest vote than anything for the rest of them shitting on plain chocolate ice cream. Plus he chose my state's dog.
Sammi Simonds
Voted for Andrew, Nick was a close second. Waffle dog had me saying “maple walnut” out loud while I watched.
LZ
Nick wins… Gavin was just safe and uninteresting… lets be real, sorry Gavin. Lets go NICK!
Thindler's Lisp
Eric wins solely off vanilla and egg nog. The man knows food. Kinda odd he loves egg nog and not candy corn though. To me they have a similar sweet creaminess.
Ken B
Choosing plain, non French, vanilla ice cream but critical of plain chocolate is insane. Automatic vote for Gav.
Nick K.
I would eat the most of Geoff's selection. Never cared for plain chocolate ice cream so Gavin lost me on that one.
Wyatt S
Can’t believe I’m not voting for Geoff or Nick on this one, brutal draft
RegulationKiwi
Questiooooooooooon, Are you guys gonna have a dog and cream month for the winner? Each week you try the pairings and rate them. OR would you consider having a 5 month worst to best pairings based on this poll? Never mind, I'll just vote.
Dakota Brown
This was honestly the most unhinged draft yet and I love it. I don't know that I think pairing dogs & cream is ever a good idea, but I know Eric had the best list of dogs and one of the best lists of cream
Jake Mitchell
Im going crazy, all of andrews pairings were S or A tier, the perfect list
Eric
Not one dog left without cream
Arielle G
I think you all did a great job trying to pair two things I would never ever eat together, hot dogs and ice cream. Gotta hand it to Andrew because I love black cherry (assuming that's close to burgundy cherry) ice cream and respect the Waffle Dog + Maple Nut combo. Honestly I got a little lost in all the dog variants, had no idea there were so many named types of hot dogs. Learned a lot, thanks crew.
Nicholas Wait
The only time I wished there was a "No one" option. Loved the video but... man.... those combos would be badddd
Spoon
I picked Gavin not because I liked his picks, but he just had the least offensive picks
Tereza Fraňková
I can't believe the strawberry slander. Geoff had the best creams, but overall Gavin was the best
Eddie Slegel
Very very rare Gavin draft W
Alan Reynolds
I voted Andrew just for his mostly basic dogs, I'm a weirdo and don't like relish, mayo, chili or many of the popular dog toppings aside from ketchup/mustard, and I only ever eat hot dogs at home or a cookout/barbecue I've never bought a dog at a restaurant or food stand.
Chimp Steinham
There are smoked dogs
Flailing Pariah
Don't care for dogs. Gavin's cream selection smokes the others.
Jake McCune
Geoff was my #2 until he fell apart in the last round. Andrew moved into second, but Gavin was always my frontrunner.
Anthony Dewitt
While some of them had good looking dogs with a decent pairing, only Nick had a list that didn't include something foul in the ice cream
Lemur Wetsuit
andrew had me with French Vanilla, Burgundy Cherry, and that picture of Waffle.
Rob Prittie
Chocolate ice cream by itself is pure 🗑️
Eric
That’s everytime though, gotta give the regulation crew a chance to win! Haha
Eric
Chocolate ice cream so good
Matthew Hughes
Waffle dog and syrup got me that is synergy right there.
Kevin Clarke
I have a regulation goldfish brain so I always need to rewatch these drafts when the poll comes out.
Seth Heder
Eric is the best salesman of the group
Sablever
I scored it based on the number of perfect pairings, so Andrew: 2, Gavin: 2, Nick: 1, Geoff: 1, Eric: 0.5 (minus half for the 2nd round monstrosity)
Aria S
Wow how did Andrew not run away with this? He didn't have the best dogs or creams but his pairings were perfect
Saun Tonkin-McAtee
Eric is absolutely insane for thinking Vanilla is better than Chocolate ice cream lmao
Andrew Corliss
Should there be an Option in the Poll that we the Audience are the ones who truly won?
jacob schultz
My Midwest ass take has to be nick because chicago dog trumps everything else.
Avlin Starfall
All the dogs sound good but the ice cream choices for most was just foul.
Ian Morrison
Maybe the hardest draft to vote for because I don't want to eat any of these combinations
Colin Curtis
Andrew: (Classic Dog, French Vanilla), (Everything Bagel dog, Burgundy Cherry), (Waffle dog, Maple Nut), (Puka dog, Banana Nut Fudge) Gavin: (Italian Dog, Coffee), (Fenway Frank dog, Chocolate), (Reindeer dog, Peppermint Stick), (Red Snapper dog, Chocolate Ribbon) Nick: (Chicago Dog, Pineapple Sherbet), (Danger Dog, Rocky Road Nut), (Coney Island dog, Chocolate Chip), (Dodger dog, Chocolate Almond) Geoff: (Cheese Coney Dog, Vanilla Burnt Almond), (The Ripper dog, Chocolate Fudge), (Okie dog, Lemon Crisp), (New York System Weiner dog, Strawberry) Eric: (Seattle Dog, Vanilla), (Sonoran Dog, Peppermint Fudge Ribbon), (Half Smoke dog, Eggnog), (White Hot dog, Chocolate Mint)
Taylor Hickey
Eric for sure. Seattle Dog is legendary a masterpiece
Borfman
That’s definitely his star pick
David Mead
Nick had the best picks.
John Garbuzinski
It would be really helpful if everyone's draft picks were included in the polls (or maybe in a comment to avoid spoilers), hard to remember the entire draft
Libby Goldstein
Had to vote for Eric just for sticking it to Arizona.
Dhuvy
Givin' it to the Big Dog Creamer!
Andreas Brilke
Yeah, I agree 💪
Brooke
Aaaargh this is hard to pick
Matthew Kimmich
Most of them have some high highs and low lows but Geoff’s is nothing but hits.
megan mazerolle
I hate onions so Andrew was my only option. Which is a shame since all but 1 of his creams were bleh.
StuKindaGuy
Eric with the spicy dogs and the mint creams took it home for me
Archery Contest
Looking forward to the Drafts Draft in 2025
Alex
This is the first time I’ve struggled to choose but gavins Italian coffee logic has won me over