Worst Song Draft Poll
🕑 Added 2025-03-25 17:00:15 +0000 UTCWho won the draft?
Comments
Samuel Dees
Eric I’m sorry I doubted your hatred of Yeah! By Usher. I got in a car accident while it was playing this morning
Raisa
They should all win.
Helepolis
F**k baby shark
Variam
Just as predicted it looks like Nick wom
BlackWolf294
I knew I was voting for Nick as soon as he picked My Humps. And Baby Shark just sealed the deal
Matthew Hughes
I did not have strong opinions here, that being said, Nick did declare at the start he was winning and today I feel like rewarding that gumption. Who knows if I would tommorrow but today that gets my vote.
CrystalOnyx
No. Because I can only vote for who I think is best. Doesn't mean who I think is the worst. If somebody gets fewest votes for favorite doesn't mean they were everybody's least favorite. They could of been 2nd on everybody's poll.
Caleb Kneeshaw
Wouldn't that be the person with the least votes?
CrystalOnyx
Since this is a worst songs draft. Can we also get a poll for worst draft?? Makes sense to me
Tom Bruynell
My picks would be just what I needed by the cars, rude by MAGIC!, billionaire by Bruno mars and some other guy and Christmas shoes by John Mcnicholl,
Kevin Clarke
There was always some out of tune, tone deaf ass hole that killed the vibe of every house party trying to play Wonderwall.
Don L
I can't hate Blurred Lines too much because Weird Al's Word Crimes is so good in concept, execution, and comedy.
Joakim XwIIcK Lundberg
Regulation Algorithm comment! Thanks for all the hard work on these videos/podcasts/streams lads! Eric's my winner here for sweet caroline alone. And Gavin's singer and song is the same as "alice, who the f is alice" song by smokie. every singer at a resort place/town have their own modified classic
TimShaw19284163519
I would definitely be most miserable if I was stuck listening to Andrews list lol the man is a genius
Regulation Brenton
I think Andrew was referring specifically to the US National Anthem, not the concept of National Anthems. Unless Eric thinks the US one is the default, and all others are versions?
Psilocvbin
I have to go with the man who cant eat after dark, Gizmo! These picks are definitely bad. Everyone else picked songs that are overplayed or bad but these feel factually bad, plus sports have nothing to do with American freedom so it always feels like pandering to patriotism
Alex
Well, you will be disappointed
Alex
*consuming all the poop - stigbink *It's hard being an alien - iamsophia *Friday - Rebecca black *Cha Cha slide - dj Casper * Get low - little John Ive been thinking about this for 2 days. This is my official list. If anyone sees this. Please look into these songs. You won't be disappointed.
Robert Trimble
Gavin had my vote with Imagine Dragons, and sealed it with U2.
Tom Cooney
Geoff it's ok to like mainstream things 😂. Just let yourself enjoy stuff man
Natalie
Andrew automatically wins by picking the national anthem
Death's Little Helper
I have to vote for Geoff just because I hate Portugal the Man so so much.
Cpt Adder
Nick must win, he got the first vote he declared it his winning day so he wins
Robert Root
The other ones were good but Geoff's hit so much deeper
Ethan
Everyone gets my vote ,they’re all bad songs
NATHAN GREER
Gavin wins overall, Andrew wins for comedy. Every pick on his list had me belly laughing
TelestoTBK
Eric. Completely agree with everything he said about Mr Brightside. As a millenial, Hate that song with a burning passion.
Kyle Oldham
I dont understand how Geoff is doing so poorly
Aven
I think I got to give it to Gavin. Blurred Lines and Swoon are in their own category of trash, er rubbish.
Ken B
A lot of these songs were fine for the time they came out but radio and commercials ruined them. I voted for Andrew.
Doogie
leave my boy out of this
Doogie
good one
Doogie
this 🙌🏼
Doogie
Red solo cup was a strong start and hard to beat. Plus with the follow up of Hey There Delilah has always rubbed me the wrong way like nick said.
Chris
Be careful of my feelings please.
Chris C.J Jones
He didn’t say anything that wasn’t true about those unlikeable twats.
EssKayAye
Most of this was an "overplayed" list rather than actual bad songs. Not impressed with any of them, really.
Kev8294
Geoff had me in on the first pick and a couple other but the proclaimers no
Liam Whitehouse
This was a tough pick, a bunch of hated songs are on this list from all parties but i picked eric
dylan bebbington
Can we vote for a redo? Never disagreed with a draft so much hahaha. The only pick I agreed with was in the honourable mentions. That Lizzo song. Fuck me dead I hate it
Jacob Dooley
Geoff wins on wonderwall alone
Justin Allen
Are we voting who has the worst list or the best list?
Tyler Hart
Everyone else was immediately competing for 2nd after Eric hit that 1/2 swing of Mr Brightside/Sweet Caroline
Stryix
Sweet Caroline is the worst song in history and it isn't even close. Eric could've picked that and my 3 favorite songs ever and he'd still win.
Zachary
Generally speaking, Pop is purposefully generic and inoffensive as the main goal is making money not art. So I'm not surprised to see a lot of these but people taking offense is funny. That said, Sweet Caroline puts Eric over the top for me. The amount of parties or bars where I had to go outside until dozens of people finished screeching it off key really takes the cake for me here.
Crimmy
I'm the same age as Eric, and I feel like he shot me point blank in the chest.
Chris
Geoff I love you, but the Oasis hate really hurt me :(
fundued games
ok but nick wins simply becuse of babby shark i nanny that i have to calim myself every time that song plays
Ryan4pie
I was certain he would have the most, disappointing!
Tuomas L
I think Baby Shark is by far the most enjoyable of Nick’s picks.
Amanda Bain
If you didn’t vote for Eric your not a rat pissed off millennial
Jacob Harvey
I was SHOCKED when I voted for Geoff and he had the least votes
Norm
Andrew’s votes for The Dusk Boys is way too funny not to win.
Chris C.J Jones
Yeah there was a lot of “I personally hate this INCREDIBLY POPULAR song and so it’s bad. And Andrew was doing a bit so Nick wins by default
Rachel Foor
Eric lost me at Mr. Brightside and, yes, I am a basic white millennial. He clocked that song's intended audience 100%.
Piotr Gruszczyński
Fun draft but I don't think anyone drafted a lot of actually bad songs. Nick wins by default by drafting Baby Shark.
Shinfo2013
In my teens I worked at a bowling alley on the weekends and they played the same cd during all of the birthday parties that started with YA and then Mr Brightside. Eric wins for personal reasons.
Brady Huber
Wonderwall worst song on the list
Bitch Puddin
I'm really surprised no one picked the uma numa song
Sarah Dawn Richardson
This draft seemed to be a personal attack against my music tastes as a millenial, but that's okay. Nick won it fair and square with Red Solo Cup and Baby Shark.
Bitch Puddin
Baby Shark really clinched it for Nick
Tilgare
Nick out to an early lead - I ended up going Gav, but it was a close call. Radioactive pushed me over the edge - that fucking song got TOO MUCH playtime. Everywhere for every reason. I think I liked their stuff at first and I can't even listen to any of their music anymore.
Elven Costello
Andrew out here not getting political 🇨🇦
sparkbears
Blessed be thee, recapper of the draft!
Saucy Mods
Red Solo Cup was for the instant win.
Mikayla Matz
I probably would have gone with Gavin, but I'm guilty of loving Radioactive... and Sweet Caroline, but that was Eric and I digress.
Joshua Neditch
Hey There Delilah was on my list, so Nick automatically wins!
Shignett23
Eric wins for me purely based on sweet Caroline. It should be unforgivable to shout 'so good, so good' when it is not and never has been part of the song
Shignett23
Tubthumping on side A and the radio edit of Tubthumping on side B was my first ever cassette...
mitzt
I'm split on a lot of these picks but my hatred for Red Solo Cup alone is enough to call Nick the winner. Fuck that noise. Geoff would have been my next choice for Tubthumping and 500 miles otherwise.
Lori Lindo
Nick understands the regulation audience with his choices
Dai
Each a pretty solid list, but Eric's opening salvo won it for me, honestly.
Aaron Splawn
The pure hate that I have for tubthumping alone is why I'm voting Geoff
Cullain Herring
Nick is ssooo good at drafts, he really is a regulation guy he’s got enough of every man in him.
MidnightArticuno
Nick’s is the only list full of awful songs from top to bottom
Sammi Simonds
Landslide victory for the MechaNick
Liam hession
Red solo cup is just too good of a bad song for nick to lose.
Sirak108
If Andrew had made real picks along with the National Anthem then I'd probably go with him. Since he didn't Nick wins.
Chance Multhoff
Hear me out, Eric is always hysteric. He gave a very hipster list. I say we give him the new nickname HypstEric. Also Nick wins
Matt Smith
Nick. Easy. Although someone needed to pick that damn Christmas shoes song.
Chris Dye
Nick wins. While most of the other songs I do not like but the Hey there Delilah song drives me crazy! I mock it every time it comes on.
Mo
Andrew’s was more mid picks than worsts. Nick’s list was the only one of the others that didn’t have a song that I unironically consider a banger on it so I picked him
Joshua Overland
I am real. Mr Bright side can eat a bag of fuck off, and won't be welcome back for seconds. Absolute A-grade drivel Yeah is annoying and overplayed, and I never got why it appealed in the first place
Corey R
Andrew picking the US National Anthem was so out of left field and I'm here for it!
Sam
voting for Nick because My Humps was stuck in my head all day yesterday and I’m furious
Thindler's Lisp
It was between Nick and Eric for me. I voted Eric but Nick with a major lead is also great to see
Raty Boy Troy
He put Mr brightside and yeah by usher. Dude could have put those in a catchiest or best songs draft and then your claim would be halfway decent. His last pick was something only him and 39 other people had listened to before including the band that made it 🤣 get real
Gavin Olsen
Eric hates fun. Geoff hates catchy choruses in otherwise alright songs. Nick won this one.
Avlin Starfall
Nick overall. Eric's last song is the best worst on the list but couldn't give it when he had Mr. Brightside, I like that song.
Raty Boy Troy
Looking at the draft board at the end, it is hands down nicks game. He nailed it.
Tobias Wallin
Still watermelon sugar song should’ve been the 1 seed
David Pinto
For me a lot of Geoff, Gavin and Eric's songs I could listen to if I was in the mood for it but all of Nick's were terrible especially when you examine them just a hair closer than surface level
John Samuel
Nick had some good picks in this one, not surprised he's winning
Flailing Pariah
Andrew wins this on the anthems thing alone for me
Ryan Woods
Nick: Red Solo Cup, My Humps, Hey there Delilah, Baby Shark Andrew: Dusk Boys x2, Why Must I Cry, National Anthem Gavin: Blurred Lines, Radioactive, Vertigo, Swoon Geoff: Wonderwall, Tubthumping, I’m Gonna Be (500 Miles), Feel It Still Eric: Mr. Brightside, Sweet Caroline, Yeah!, Twinkle Twinkle
Colin Curtis
Nick: Red Solo Cup by Toby Keith, My Humps by Black Eyed Peas, Hey There Delilah by Plain White T's, Baby Shark Andrew: Hard 2 Breathe by the Dusk Boys, Why Must I Cry by Reh Dogg, U.F.Whoa by the Dusk Boys, National Anthem Gavin: Blurred Lines by Robin Thicke, Radioactive by Imagine Dragons, Vertigo by U2, Swoon by The Chemical Brothers Geoff: Wonderwall by Oasis, Tubthumping by Chumbawamba, I'm Gonna Be (500 Miles) by The Proclaimers, Feel It Still by Portugal. The Man Eric: Mr Brightside by The Killers, Sweet Caroline by Neil Diamond, Yeah! by Usher, Twinkle Twinkle by Leah Kate
Felipe Arcos
I voted gavin but Nick's red solo cup almost did it for me. That song fucking sucks
Eduardo Lopez
Every song on the draft was terrible but theres so much more we could probably do a worst songs draft 2
Yakuzie
Eric, i was with you until the Usher "Yeah" pick. That song still slaps
Paul S
As a Nats fan I can’t vote for Nick. Baby Shark is the reason we won in ‘19
spectorpanzers
As a Millennial Geoff and Eric's lists sucked Nick is winning by a mile though
Joshua Overland
Eric won this draft straight up, in the first round. Everything after that was window dressing
Max Godfrey
Nick and I could not be *more* on the same page.
Elizabeth Joyce
Poor JDoolz catching strays with the Dusk Boys songs 😂 also, I used to like Blurred Lines before I heard the lyrics. Such a r*pey song 😬
The Admirals of N
Nick was already winning for me, and then he brought out the closer of Baby Shark
BurtStanky
Eric would've had it for me if not for the Usher pick. Geoff gets my vote instead, though I don't feel strongly about the Portugal. The Man song