Leaqio.com
shaneivey from patreon
shaneivey patreon

Swords & Sorceries: The Shieldbearer Archetype for 5E Fighters

🕑 Added 2019-10-29 21:20:24 +0000 UTC
Swords & Sorceries: The Shieldbearer Archetype for 5E Fighters

Comments

Arc Dream Publishing

I could change my mind after seeing it in play, but I don't see it as overpowered. It doesn't come in until you get 7 fighter levels, it applies only once a turn, and it has has situational prerequisites.

Ken

Putting a cost like Bonus Action on Phalanx Tactics also makes it a player decision or option, instead of an "always on" perk. A Shieldbearer would then have to choose between a Shield Bash or Phalanx Tactics. And knocking someone prone would grant advantage in melee, BTW, so some food for thought there.

Ken

On PHALANX TACTICS: Jim Davis of WebDM talked about how they used the optional Flanking rule from the DMG and it was a huge mistake. Basically, flanking grants advantage. And if you can get advantage relatively easily without consuming resources or action economy, then you'd never use Cunning Action to hide, or Invisibility or whatnot. Fighters do not have an abundance of ways to get advantage without relying on their teammates abilities, and I think Phalanx Tactics grants advantage too easily. Maybe it should cost a Bonus Action or a resource like Superiority Dice.


More Creators