Red Web patreon

Mystery Madness: Vote for the Ultimate Unsolved Case

🕑 Added 2025-03-01 17:00:14 +0000 UTC

Comments

Red Web

Great choice for next year! We started with 64 out of our current 225 or so topics, so it was a hard choice just to get started!

NamelessGuardsman

Idk, I didn’t see Van Meter Visitor anywhere… maybe next year?

Red Web

I edited the post to include the link, but you can also find the post here: https://www.patreon.com/posts/124242531

Musica_Ficta

The link says that round one is don’t voting and I can’t see how to vote for the next round.

Red Web

We will update this post with the weekly recaps and polls for each round! Round 1 Recap is available NOW

Red Web

It was tough to only pick 64! Definitely getting that one involved next year, good idea.

Joseph Grimmrose

Lake City will always be one of my top favorites, that and Hinterkeifeck

Noah-true

The amount of times I've relistened to these episodes makes the vote so hard- yall put some of these against eachother on purpose. Not adding The Secret is criminal

Rachel Foor

Not including the Yuba County Five is criminal

Santiago Rodriguez

I just happened to listen to Circleville letters the other day and my god i hope it goes far cause I was going crazy just as much as Fredo was during it.

Milkasaurous

Yo. Jersey Devil to take it all! I'm from New Jersey, I've been through the Pine Barrens plenty of times, I've got multiple books on the Jersey Devil, and I'm a huge hockey fan; Let's Go Devils! Also: I wish I had some kind of sourcing for this but, I was just recently over at my mother's house and she had the news on (I think it might have been News 12 New Jersey) and they were doing a whole story about how it was quite possible that Jack the Ripper may have finally just been identified via DNA testing.

Flammabell

this just sent me back down a 3 hour rabbit hole about dyatlov pass and did you guys check out dyatlovpass.com for research at all?they have SO much information and a ton of original sources and documents and i would love to hear yalls take on their tree theory

Melanie Adams

Mothman vs the Watcher house was haaaaaard Took me a bit to decide between Bloody Benders and Restricted Stalker too

Melanie Adams

I googled lol

Russ

putting Roswell and Cicada 3301 up against each other this early is devious, those are two of my favs!!

EchthelionII

Completely agree with this! I knew a couple, had a vague idea on some, & didn't remember most of them.

EchthelionII

Same! I didn't remember/know at least half of them.

EchthelionII

I do not remember most of these, so I just did my best with what I thought they were.

Sommer

Oh man I wish there was a one or two sentence description on these so I could call up my memories better. I'm too oooooold.

Ashley Lucey

My only hardest decision in this was Zodiac against Jack the Ripper lol. I bet mothman will make it far

Tyler Diamond

Definitely can’t call the entire bracket, but I’m going to call the winner here and now. I think it’s going to be dyatlov.

James Russell

Man I had to go back and refresh my memory on some of those lol.

The Admirals of N

I really like the idea, but if I may suggest one thing. For each "combatant", maybe add a one or two descriptive sentence to remind those with bad memories (me, I'm one of those people) what each topic was.

Conor Russell

Gotta hold out hope that Bonnybridge will make it as far as possible (I'm delusional and know ive got no chance against the mighty Mothman). COME ON SCOTLAND!!! 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

NixieShimo

Some of these match ups I couldn't remember well enough. So I picked the one that was more fun to say. Guess this means it's time for a Red Web marathon to refamiliarize myself with the contestants.