The Open Marriage Murder - Dan "The Wolf" Serafini
🕑 Added 2025-09-02 01:43:00 +0000 UTCThis week, a major league baseball pitcher, who had a hard time staying on one team, or even in one league. His journeyman career took him all over the world, but his troubles started at home. He traded in one wife, for a new wife, costing himself millions of dollars. Opened a failed bar, that the "Bar Rescue" tv show couldn't save. But his real trouble started when he decided to shoot his in laws. A murder trial reveals an open marriage, an unlikely accomplice, and all kinds of crazy stuff!!
Try to embrace your Italian heritage, travel the world, being cut from different baseball teams, and murder your in laws, with the help of your wife's friend, who also happens to be your girlfriend with Dan "The Wolf" Serafini!!
Check us out, every Tuesday!
We will continue to bring you the biggest idiots in sports history!!
Hosted by James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman
Donate at... patreon.com/crimeinsports or with paypal.com using our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com
Get all the CIS, STM & YSO merch at crimeinsports.threadless.com
Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things CIS, STM & YSO!!
Contact us on...
instagram.com/smalltownmurder
facebook.com/crimeinsports
crimeinsports@gmail.com
Comments
Dennis James Mcintosh
I learned so much about baseball from this sad story. Thanks for another great tale.
Matt Bechard
Another crazy but awesome fuckin story guys!!! Thanks, look forward to new episodes every week, don’t listen to anything else!!!
Mackenzie Engler
I use my Italian family’s Christmas Eve dinner as a litmus test for the relationship. If you can get through the feast of the seven fishes things might just work out
That Aussie Cunt
Me to
Stephen T
I traded my Frank Thomas rookie card for a Gregg Jeffries rookie card + 1 other (possibly a Steve Avery rookie). Live and learn I suppose.
Nikki Mendez
My great-grandfather's family came to America from French Canada (as it was called). Immediately, his mother said, "In this house, we speak American." and the French language left our family line. That's how it was in the late 1800s.
Seamheads.com
I don't have a dog in the fight--I liked Dusty Baker (more as a player than manager) and I was a huge fan of Rod Beck, even before he joined my Red Sox. But please stop perpetuating the myth that Baker ruined Beck's career and Shooter once pitched in 11 straight games. The most consecutive games Beck threw in his entire career was five. Even in 1992 when Beck pitched a career-high 92 innings under Giants manager Roger Craig, the most consecutive games he appeared in was three. Beck also admitted that he had bone spurs in his elbow—and had for years--but elected to continue pitching rather than have surgery to remove them. He finally had surgery in May, 1999 and missed only two months of the season. It wasn’t until he was ineffective in 1999 that he finally decided to undergo surgery and that came after Cubs manager Jim Riggleman used Beck in a Natonal League high 81 games, in which he had him throw in five consecutive games twice and four twice. Riggleman later said he used Beck in 12 to 15 games in 1998 that he shouldn’t have but had no choice because of “other people’s failures.” James knew Beck personally and I never met the man, so I’m guessing Shooter most likely blamed Baker, especially if he developed bone spurs under Baker’s watch. I blame Riggleman but I wasn’t there.
Ryan Mountain
Not that I care bc I love the content… but I’ve been a patreon subscriber for over a year and I’ve never gotten a shoutout.
Benjamin Fleming
It was very obvious in the bar rescue episode that his wife was a huge enabler of his behavior, so it doesn't surprise me that she acted in that way about his guilt. Dan's still a piece of shit, tho, and deserved everything he got.
Benjamin Fleming
I've been waiting for this one. Absolutely loved it. You guys are the best!
Seamheads.com
“Everyday Eddie!”
Amy Sousa
Perhaps the ultimate irony here is that “serafini” means “little angel” 😇 in Italian lol
Melissa Bilotta
I grew up in a very small town (technically a village) in PA, where everyone immigrated from the same small town in Italy. One of our neighbors was an Irish guy who loved to tell the story of his first dinner with his future wife’s family. It was pasta, of course, with chicken feet in the sauce.
Dena Werling
Growing up with my dad’s parents being immigrants from Germany plus they were from such a small town their dialect was very different from most parts of Germany and very poor… so many of James’ Italian stories ring a lot of bells for my fam too 😂
Justin Simmons
😂
Blake
Got a shout out from Whisman! yaaaay indeed! (Although I think my message depressed him. lol)
Kath Finn
The return of Paul Calhoun! I miss Bobby Colorado...
Fredrika Farfalu
So much sports in this one…
Stephen Watts
In Ireland there's a similar term for Irish that claim Irishness but are removed from Ireland, a Plastic Paddy it's used a lot for Irish Americans.
LC
P.S. Think I might have my original Tune Squad jersey in storage… thanks for the reminder!
LC
Deep cut with the Space Jam Newman quote!! I’m slow…. And large…. *Daffy Duck* And a DORK!!
Laurie Katherine
Me, too! Never heard my name!
Matora
Is there a way to listen to this on desktop without the app? Patreon says not.
michael
Boys, boys, I know this is a baseball story but so you know who else went to J. Serra HS? A guy named Tom Brady… ever hear of him?😂. (Btw Jimmy, I’m still waiting for my “shoutout.”)
Gregory McGrath
You mentioned Otis Nixon in this episode and a couple others . You have suggested he might not be the Face of baseball, or not quite the most handsome player ever. Well I have a story. Back in the day when he was playing for the Red Sox with Willie McGee and followed him in the batting order. My wife decided to make an effort to watch baseball with me. I watched a lot of sports back then but she didn’t. So she sits down on the couch with me and Willie came up to bat. She immediately said “Oh my god he is hideous “ I knew Otis was next to bat and couldn’t resist saying “Wait until you see the next guy.” Otis stepped into the batter’s box and my wife said “ Oh no! That’s enough.” She never sat down with me again to watch sports. Otis Nixon cock blocked me . Not my favorite player. You have comented several times and I decided it was time to share that.
Danielle Carter
I'm a granddaughter of Sicilian grandparents. I'm also from North Jersey. James has the different types of Italians down. Although my grandpa did use an "English" name as a boxer.
Erik Turner
He was also on an episode of Bar Rescue. He owned the bar
landeno sereni
I’m a wonderbread wop😂 I love that term
Francis Olsson
If his wife doesn't win the golden Gillreetha award then the Scummies are rigged.
Smalls (smallenoughtofit)
So, in the case of the dog, Maggie: TLDR: Maggie was almost certainly trying to wake Wendy *despite* the blood, not because of it. TW: not a fun topic, dogs and dead bodies Behavioralists believe that even when dogs bite their owners after they've passed, they're probably trying to wake them. They're also likely biting out of panic at first, then their wires get crossed with new input that may trigger eating behavior from there. They also might be trying to clean the scene to avoid attracting large predator/scavengars, such as bears, on an instinctual level. There's little clear, systematic data gathered about this, but evidence suggests that dogs will wait a long time and, in some cases, will actually starve first.
Ryan Oakes
Good episode 5 Stars James and Jimmie
Jonas Jesus
WHO THE FUCK IS SAMANTHA SCOTT???
Elizabeth Rutherford
Yaaaaaayyy!
Jimmy
The wolf!!!
Maicie Lingwall
Everyday Eddie Guardado!
Marcella Fletcher
Haven’t gotten my shout out! Hope you’re getting my money 🙂
Temple Corson
3 fingers is where u went wrong, punch with index and middle KNUCKLES not philanges to stay safe
Zach
Cal Raleigh would like a word boys!
Brendan Ables
Yaaaay! I love the baseball episodes
Ernest Roher
In MLB you have slots they can pay you over your slot value. Also, if you play Divison 1 baseball like at Miami. You are bound to play for 3 years.
Raven Knickerbocker
Haha. James is 100% correct. I punched a boy in the head/face a few times when I was in middle school and ended up with an identical injury. Three fingers and two bones in my hand busted. I spent 8 weeks in a cast covering my middle, ring and pinky fingers going all the way to my elbow. Very typical Boxers fractures.
Zach Hollander
Wooooooooooooooooo