Leaqio.com
Mage's lit pit from patreon
Mage's lit pit patreon

A Saga of Tanya the Chansey: 40

🕑 Added 2025-09-19 21:46:08 +0000 UTC

Comments

eh dontlisten

I hope no one else realizes this. Because I do NOT want to rewrite that fight scene. It was a MASSIVE pain. Uhhhh. Wait. Ok. I can square this. Most of the time, in professional battles, it's not an issue, as arenas are big enough for it not to matter. It's only when the arena is the size of a tennis court that ring out becomes a problem. So there are rules, kinda soft rules, but rules nonetheless. Of different 'kinds' of ring out. Things like whirlwind, roar, or just grabbing a 'mon and throwing them out of the arena does not 'knock them out' but instead triggers a swap. Because you want the fight to stick inside the arena and, as you noticed, it wouldn't be fair. HOWEVER, if you hit a 'mon hard enough that they go flying out of the arena and they don't immediately make every effort to get back IN the arena, then it's a ring out DQ. In a single sentance its: "If you're trying to remove them from the arena, they swap. However, if you're trying to kick their teeth in and they just so HAPPEN to be removed from the arena, that's a DQ." Simple, kinda subjective, but things are complicated and almost any battle done on arenas small enough for it to matter aren't important enough or dangerous enough for more codified rules.

Empty Shelf

My only issue with this battle is that, from a practical standpoint, a "ring out" shouldn't be treated as a KO, but as a forced switch. That's how it's treated in-game with moves that specifically remove Pokemon from the arena (Roar, Whirlwind, etc.), and there are any number of moves that, in a non-gamified environment, would almost incidentally have the same effect (Surf, Earthquake, etc.) It's a bit too easily exploitable to realistically be considered a valid way to win a battle.

KAFFING

I guess the problem with Tanya and Amelia is that Tanya is usually the commander not the one to be commanded. Maybe Tanya would take a reverse of roles to help Amelia be a more effective "leader" and thereby better trainer.


More Creators