drumrolltonyreacts patreon

🟢VOTE for next Tier 1 Anime

🕑 Added 2024-05-14 18:01:00 +0000 UTC

Comments

Moist Palm

Def go for Fmab's english dub, If you end up watching it

Plz Help

Fullmetal dub is absolutely peak.

Yuyu

100% agreed, where in majority anime jp is the better watch, this is one of the few exceptions to the rule for very good reason.

Hugo Abilleira

please, do not watch any anime with the english dub. Please.

Marthan

I think he's reserving a patreon anime slot for oldish, more classic anime. He watched Death Note, and is now watching Code Geass in place of it, so Evangelion probably wouldn't fit on this poll. FMAB is definitely a classic but it's newer than most people realize since it only started airing in 2009. But at the rate he's going through Code Geass I'm sure the opportunity will come up for Evangelion.

Scalchop

If Fullmetal is chosen, watch the English dub!! The anime community agrees it's one of the best dubs out there, and a lot of people consider it better than the Japanese version (myself included, and I'm someone who almost always watches the latter).

Walt D

Hopefully all of the FMAB folks who understand how important this staple is in anime watch order, can unite for this vote. I love the list as a whole.

makotheQ60

Oh don't get me wrong. I love brotherhood. I just never can understand the hate for demon slayer yet it still remains one of the most popular today so it's a self-contained Hate I guess. You only really see it in the comments of reactors

Walt D

Demon Slayer is awesome. FMAB is a staple though. I love both. However, watching order may be a factor.

The Insane CSGO Moments

If you're watching 2 episodes per week, it would indeed take you 10 years to finish. In that case, you could opt for the alternative of watching 2 reactions per week, each consisting of 2 episodes(4 episode a week). This way, it would take you 5 years. That's quite a commitment, especially considering that you're planning to live a long life.(As you delve deeper into the world of anime, your likelihood of not watching One Piece dwindles towards zero.)But of course that's your choice.

DrumRollTony

I think it would take 9 years if I did 2 ep a week. That is lmao not realistic

Kenji

worst anime

Kenji

wdym

The Insane CSGO Moments

yeah and i'am ready to pay for this

Kenji

but you could also gain a huge fanbase and having a long ass show like op the payment will be there for a long time (not sayin do it for the money or op fans would dip again after u finish op) is also a good business idea i would say

Kenji

im waiting for one piece btw did u finish aot?

Kenji

xcept ds

Coen

Its just an extremely simple story. Incredible animation and fights, but some obnoxious characters make it less enjoyable. I've seen it all and enjoyed it, but the other 3 anime in this poll surpass it easily.

makotheQ60

I will never understand the hate for demon slayer yet it remains one of the most popular around so it's a niche group that thinks it's trash.. oh well one day Tony will see it and be like I should have saw this sooner

SKAOG

FMAB, Mob Psycho and Re:Zero are all great shows, so even if FMAB wins, I hope in future polls the other 2 appear so that you eventually watch them all

SKAOG

No, OPM is a parody, he should watch more normal anime to understand why OPM is so good. Watching Mob Psycho 100 from the start is fine, he can get used to the art.

d_swordfish

Evangelion...

TheGoblerTrainsMovinIn

I'm so fucking hyped for that remake, the greatest story in anime but made by the AoT guys in 2024, I still cant believe it's real

Ryo

Holy crap how do even choose from these they're all goated

Nake

Both Mob Psycho 100 and FMAB are masterpiece to me. But i recommend watching One Punch Man first to get used to the author’s drawing style.

Meru Tenchin

Not every show he watches must be masterpiece in writing

EdTheAlchemist

Fmab ftw

Sam

They’re both great shows. Hopefully eventually both happen

TheGoblerTrainsMovinIn

its ok, Tony seems to have some sort of time magic to be able to pump out this much content and also teach and go to shows, ect ect

SinuHan

Good 15 years ago? So youre saying its not good? Why not?

SinuHan

I love Re: Zero, but it clearly wont win so Ill go with FMAB, one of my favorite animes. It is just a great story, and the music is lovely imo, plus the dub is amazing so it would be easier to watch as well

Jarod S

All great choices and shows I think you'll enjoy so happy with any winner really. One point though is they've all got fairly high episode counts so might take a while to get through but your schedule is already packed as it is.

DrumRollTony

Value add! 🤘🤘🎶🎶🤙🤙🤙 Thanks!

Xer0FeaR

I will like to mention that this isn't the last vote ever. Another show will end and some of these may be on the next poll. Look at Violet Evergarden. That was on a lot of polls and here it is. I am in no rush at all. Tony being new to anime, having a musical background makes it a very enjoyable watch. I've seen other anime reactors and I don't get the same out of them as I do Tony. Let's all just chill, hangout, and enjoy what's to come.

Queen Ruka

Eye candy sure, but outside of that its easily the weakest show here

Detective Gamez

thought he would be into seeing overlord he seems to like the premise.

Greenleaf

Eh no one needs to watch the ovas or movie for fmab. But yeah it's a little long compared to mob being only 37+2ova.

DrumRollTony

That'd a good assessment

jonaru

probably after jojo finally finishes

TheGoblerTrainsMovinIn

maybe one day bro, but FMA:B is probably better anyway

DrumRollTony

Thx for being here 🤘

Jhon 1479

all im waiting for is HxH tbh

Martin Lamaze

I'm all for FMAB since I love its story and music, and the dub is a good one. I also find it to be one of these animes that aren't too exotic, and sometimes touching on different themes and locations than *highschool in japan* or *another isekai* is great.

Lixien

Yeah, but watching it on your own and reacting and making content out of it is not the same. Slice of Life animes like idk Yuru Camp are good shows but they aren't good for reactions.

dino

mob psycho is incredible and great show

TheGoblerTrainsMovinIn

no matter what gets picked theres gonna be some salty lads

DrumRollTony

Yusf .

for reference, demon slayer has 56 episodes and is not finished, re zero has 50 episodes and is not finished, mob psycho has 38 episodes and is finished and fmab has 64 episodes and is finished

Yusf .

will this be once a week like jjk?

DrumRollTony

But, I'm Tony. Not a "reactor". I'm a musician 😎

mattmallow

I'm sorry, I can't with FMAB. EVERY reactor does that one. I don't need another person doing Fullmetal (or Demon Slayer for that matter) I like the show, but you have Re:Zero and Mob Psycho on the poll.

AJ

I would say it's one the greatest animes. Even if you think it as overrated it's still definetely worth a watch. What would you suggest is better than FMAB today?

kail santini

I get the FMAB choice, But honestly Mob Psycho would be an amazing watch from beginning to end.

Luis Arispe

Full metal alchemist it's a classic, but take note that it's a 64 episode show with 4 ovas and a movie to watch. It's a lot of time to invest.

Logan H

One épisode per week will be soo long, in abyss case i'll not watch it. I dont like it that much

Potatex

FMA is noy even a discussion for you ngl

The Insane CSGO Moments

Well, if you don't start, you will never watch it, and if you watch it for your own pleasure, it doesn't matter how long it will be.

DrumRollTony

Maybe on the remake. I'm not going to do a show that is 1000 ep

The Insane CSGO Moments

just don't watch reactions other people will do these

Greenleaf

It's gonna take him til october at least to finish s2 anyway. October is 20 weeks away.

Lixien

Don't get me wrong, it's a good show. But I personally think it's a horrible show for a reaction series. It's a slow burner and slow burners are just boring for reactions. I don't want to wait multiple weeks until the reactor gets to the good episodes/the climax. Plus it's like 1000+ episodes. Yeah, no.

Tauren Rogue

what do you mean by todays standard? why is it overrated?

TheGoblerTrainsMovinIn

FMA:B, words cannot describe its greatness, also it has one of, If not the best dub out there, highly recommend watching dub and I don't say that very often

Meru Tenchin

Jet Man

1000 piece? never.

Queen Ruka

Better than what other options are listed here at least.

Queen Ruka

Hopefully never. You cant expect someone to sit through that.

Meru Tenchin

I might even subscribe here if demon slayer wins tbf lol

Meru Tenchin

Demon slayer is eye candy, super enjoyable one of the best animated animes today you’ll enjoy it a lot.

Sam

Not trying to be rude but this is an L take. Also not a big fan of the whole “don’t watch this thing!” comments that don’t offer anything constructive

The Insane CSGO Moments

When One piece?

ThomasShelbysLungs

I listen to FMAB music all the time

Carlos M.

Please dont do Full metal alchemist. It is overrated af, maybe good 15 years ago, but not with today´s standard.

Tuny kun

FMAB no contest. OP and ED 1 are some of my favorites. Easily top 10.

Red Menace

i mean he endure teh early bits of oshi no ko(sorry if i mispell) after that im sure anything is possible

JoeyGuy7

MOB is a lot more light hearted than the others on this list which is why I'm voting for it. Fma is good but it's another super serious show after jjk

Nick K

I reallyyy enjoy Re:Zero, but the third season is coming in October so I'm fine putting it off and voting for Mob Psycho instead. Mob is like a perfect show. It's starts great, continues to be great, and ends great. It's such a consistent level of quality, and is one of the most emotionally healthy shows to ever exist. I enjoy all of these shows though, and am perfectly happy if FMA wins because it's also a wonderful classic. Demon Slayer is also really good, but among these four it's actually the weakest for me even if it does have some really exciting moments and an overall interesting story.

Chris Hee

Re Zero is a good show, but if he ever does watch it, he has to be prepared to endure the early bits

Nick K

Yeah at the beginning I feel like that's kind of the point of his arc. If he was episode 1 Subaru for the whole show it would be a bad show

Coen

Not sure if many people like Subaru, especially in the beginning haha

Renegade

RE:Zero is one of my favorite anime of all time, but I'm not voting for it, just because it's a bit too out there. Also, Tony would hate Subaru.

Skeletan

For you? I'm voting Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. I think it's got what you're looking for moreover than the others on the list, not that the others are bad, just that they're a lot more beholden to Japanese values, beliefs, and comedy styles, very foreign stuff. The FMA: Brotherhood story is written in a pretty universal style by a single girl, Hiromu Arakawa. She not only wrote the entire story, but also made the designs for every single character, this show being far more faithful to the comic manga Arakawa created than the original adaptation from 2003.

Diego Castagnetti

i think he would really love deon slayer. Simple and cool story, cool characters, and incredible animation (same studio that animated Violet Evergarden)

Red Menace

mob psycho, you want to leave the top of all the goats fmab till last, althought im surprised at the lack of re-zero love

chrysaliszt

I haven't even watched it yet, but I know that FMAB is an absolute classic. As much as I love Mob and Re:Zero, it'd be a shame if you missed such a cultural phenomenon

jonaru

all these are just great but Full Metal Alchemist and Mob Psycho are just too good man; either of those is a w

cue

you're gonna love FMAB, the dub is really great too

Iivo

Mob Psycho 100 definitely gets my vote, great humor, story, characters, animation and music! The action scenes are very good too! Not terribly long either