FemmeForgie
patreon
Dared into Her (TG Story) - Part 1
🕑 Added 2025-08-11 01:04:00 +0000 UTCDared into Her (TG Story)
By FemmeForge
It was supposed to be a stupid late-night joke — a drunk, mean-spirited dare to humiliate the shy virgin of the group.
One ritual. A mirror. A copper bowl. A “lust offering.”
Shy, dick-starved virgin Ethan never stood a chance once his friends found that shady “summon a succubus” ritual online.
They pin him in the spotlight, ripping into him with filthy jokes about how he’d look as a woman — huge, soft tits spilling over his hands, a fat jiggling ass you could bounce coins off, and a dripping little pussy just begging for the first cock that got near it.
Ethan knew it was fake. His friends knew it was fake. That didn’t stop them from pinning him down in the filthiest way possible — teasing him, taunting him, painting vivid pictures of what he’d look like with fat tits, a perfect ass, and a dripping little pussy. They laughed, they dared, they pushed… until he said yes.
By the time it’s over, Ethan’s gone — replaced by a wide-eyed, soaking-wet slut who can barely stand without rubbing her thighs together.
Now Ethan is about to find out just how far a silly dare can go… and how hot, humiliating, and irreversible becoming the perfect fuckable plaything can really be.
Link for the PDF File: https://drive.google.com/file/d/115_mebs0rycSl5-0nyi7qi8A0EACQVdz/view?usp=drive_link
Part 1
Ethan had always been the safe one in the group — the guy you could invite to a party and count on to keep an eye on the drinks table, or give you a ride home at 2 a.m. without making it weird. Twenty-two, rail-thin, average height, brown hair that never sat right no matter how he styled it. Not ugly, just… forgettable.
The kind of guy whose name people at school remembered only when they needed help with homework.
He’d had crushes — a lot of them — but his awkward way of talking and tendency to overthink every word meant he never acted on them. His dating history was basically one and a half failed attempts, both ending before they’d even kissed. His friends joked he was a virgin, and while he never confirmed it, his uncomfortable laugh said enough.
His friends liked him, sure, but he was basically the punchline half the time. Especially when the conversation turned to sex. Mason, the cocky jock, would talk about fucking some girl in the locker room. Cass, the hot, mouthy one, would talk about her conquests in enough detail to make him squirm. Even quiet little Lila had more to brag about than him.
When the rest of the group bragged about who they’d fucked — all the sloppy hookups, girls giving head in parking lots, some wild story about doing it in a bathroom stall — Ethan would fake a laugh and make a dumb joke so no one noticed how much it stung. He’d sit there pretending he was part of the conversation, when really he was just thinking about how he’d never done any of it. Not even close.
Whenever the topic came up, Ethan would fake a laugh, make a self-deprecating joke, and hope they moved on. But they never really did. They’d nudge him, call him “dry spell,” make cracks about him being a virgin. He’d roll his eyes, but it burned every damn time.
Didn’t mean he didn’t think about sex, though. Hell, he thought about it all the time. But not the way they’d expect. He didn’t sit around imagining himself as the guy railing some girl from behind. Half the time, he was imagining being the girl.
Not because he didn’t think about sex — hell no. He thought about it constantly. But not the way they would ever imagine.
Because Ethan didn’t always picture himself as the guy doing the fucking. Half the time, he imagined being the one getting fucked.
Not in some dumb, dress-up way. Actually being one.
Big, perfect tits he could barely hold in both hands. A tight little waist and hips that made every step a sway. Panties clinging to him, riding up against a wet pussy that throbbed every time he moved.
Not as some silly cross-dressing gag. Not in a “haha wouldn’t it be weird if—” kind of way. Actually being a woman. Having tits so big and perfect they’d make shirts tight in all the right places. Feeling the weight of them bounce with every step. Having an ass that filled out jeans so well it made strangers trip over their own feet.
He’d picture the weight of those tits bouncing when he walked, the way his nipples would stick out hard under a shirt if someone brushed them. He’d think about spreading his thighs and feeling air on slick folds instead of a limp dick. Sometimes, when he was jerking off, he’d imagine looking down and seeing nothing but smooth skin and that wet little slit begging to be touched.
He’d jerk off imagining what it would feel like to have a wet, aching pussy instead of his dick. The way panties would stick when he was turned on. The rush of sliding his fingers between slick folds. The sharp, needy heat when someone touched him down there.
It would get filthier in his head, too. He’d picture himself bent over with a cock sliding into him, breasts swinging with each thrust, his moans high and needy. Or kneeling, lips wrapped around something thick, feeling drool run down his chin while his tits pressed together for the view. He’d stroke faster, dick twitching, already knowing he was gonna blow but not caring.
It didn’t stop there, either. He’d imagine the filthiest shit — bending over a bed with his hair falling over one shoulder while someone grabbed his hips and pushed in deep. Moaning so high and breathless he wouldn’t even sound like himself. Or kneeling on the floor, tits pushed together for someone to fuck, feeling their cock hit his throat while drool dripped down his chin.
Sometimes he’d stroke himself so fast he’d come in seconds just from picturing it. Other times he’d draw it out, edging until his balls hurt, imagining he already had a pussy and was grinding against a cock, desperate to come. When he finally blew, it was always messy — all over his stomach or chest — and he’d lie there panting, half disgusted and half wishing it was real.
Most nights he’d finish with his stomach sticky and his mind racing, half disgusted with himself but still rock hard again minutes later. He told himself it was just a weird fantasy, something no one could ever know about. But deep down, he wanted to know exactly how it would feel. How clothes would cling to his ass. How a low-cut top would get eyes glued to his tits. How it would feel to be dripping wet and have someone else’s hands on him, pulling him closer.
It was fucked up. It was hot as hell.
And it made him lose more sleep than he’d ever admit.
He told himself it was just idle fantasy, the kind of weird thing your brain cooks up when you’re horny and lonely. But part of him wondered what it would feel like — the way clothes would fit, the weight of a chest, the sensation between the legs being different. It scared him as much as it turned him on.
Around his friends, he buried it under sarcasm. Mason — the loud, athletic one — always teased him about never “closing the deal” with women. Cass, the gorgeous, sharp-tongued one, loved to poke at his shy streak. And Lila, quiet but wicked when she wanted to be, had a knack for making him blush with an offhand comment.
Ethan never told them he sometimes enjoyed being teased — that it felt safer than real intimacy, but also scratched an itch he didn’t want to name.
By the night of The Dare, he’d gotten used to being the butt of the joke. He played along, pretended to roll his eyes, and acted like nothing got to him.
The truth was, he wanted something to shake him out of his life — he just never imagined it would be that night, in that stupid candlelit room, surrounded by friends who thought it was all a joke… until it wasn’t.
The four of them were sprawled out in Mason’s basement — beanbags, blankets, and half-empty cans of cheap beer scattered across the carpet. The TV was on some shitty horror flick in the background, but no one was watching.
Cass had her legs draped over Lila’s lap, scrolling on her phone. Mason was leaning back against the couch, tossing popcorn into his mouth and missing half of it. Ethan sat cross-legged on the floor, nursing a warm beer and doing his best to keep up with whatever stupid conversation they were on now.
It started innocent enough — Mason talking about some girl he’d hooked up with at the gym. Then Cass chimed in with a story about a guy she’d ghosted after he came too quick. Lila even admitted to a quickie in a dressing room.
And then, like clockwork, the conversation turned to him.
“So, Ethan…” Cass drawled, eyes narrowing in that I’m about to fuck with you way. “What’s the wildest place you’ve ever done it?”
He smirked, trying to brush it off. “Uh, my dreams?”
Mason barked a laugh. “Oh my god, that’s right — you still haven’t gotten laid.” He leaned forward like he’d just remembered something. “Are you saving yourself for marriage or are you just scared of pussy?”
Ethan rolled his eyes. “Yeah, that’s exactly it. Terrified. Pussy’s my kryptonite.”
Cass grinned wickedly. “Please, you’d cream yourself if a girl even sat on your lap.”
“I wouldn’t—” he started, but Mason cut him off.
“Bro, I bet he hasn’t even seen tits in real life.”
“I’ve seen—”
Lila tilted her head, finally joining in. “Like, in person? Not counting porn?”
Ethan opened his mouth, then shut it again. The pause was all they needed.
Cass let out a loud, fake gasp. “Holy shit. You haven’t.”
“Okay, no, fuck off—”
Mason cackled. “Dude, you’re twenty-two! Do you even know what to do if you had a naked girl in front of you? Like, step one, what’s your move?”
Ethan smirked, going for sarcasm. “Uh, I’d ask her about her hopes and dreams.”
Cass snorted so hard she almost dropped her phone. “Oh my god, he would.”
“Shut up,” he said, but his ears were burning.
Mason leaned back, shaking his head. “Man, you’re one bad day away from dying a virgin.”
Lila smirked. “We should throw him a pity fuck.”
Ethan sputtered. “Jesus Christ—”
Cass’s eyes glittered. “Nah, I’ve got a better idea. We find a ritual online. Y’know, summon a succubus or something. Maybe she’ll take mercy on him.”
Mason grinned. “Yeah, let’s get him fucked by a demon. Bet even she would ghost him.”
They all laughed while Ethan sat there, cheeks hot, forcing a smile. Same routine as always — take the hits, roll with the jokes. Pretend it didn’t turn him on in the worst possible way when Cass’s voice dropped low and she talked about a girl on his lap. Pretend his mind didn’t instantly go to what if…
He took another sip of beer, letting them keep laughing, all while something twisted low in his stomach.
The four of them were holed up in Mason’s basement, the usual disaster of a sleepover — popcorn kernels in the carpet, empty soda cans and beer bottles on the table, and a crappy horror movie playing just for background noise. Cass was sprawled out across a beanbag, feet kicked up in Lila’s lap, scrolling on her phone between sips of wine. Mason sat in a camp chair tipped back on two legs, tossing a foam ball in the air. Ethan was cross-legged on the floor, hoodie sleeves half covering his hands, pretending to watch the screen.
The conversation had already drifted into hookup stories. Mason was bragging about some girl from the gym, Cass was talking about making a guy beg, and Lila even admitted to a quickie in a dressing room. Then, right on schedule, they turned to Ethan.
“So, E,” Cass said, giving him that sly grin, “where’s the weirdest place you’ve ever done it?”
Ethan smirked. “Uh… my imagination?”
They laughed. Mason leaned forward, elbows on his knees. “Man, you still haven’t gotten laid, huh? Jesus, what do you do all day? Just… jerk off and play video games?”
Ethan shrugged. “Sounds like a solid plan to me.”
Cass shook her head with mock pity. “You’d probably bust the second a girl sat on your lap.”
“Probably not,” he muttered.
That’s when Mason grinned, and you could tell he was about to take it a step too far. “Nah, see… I don’t even think you’re the lap guy. You give off more of a… bottom vibe. Like, I can’t even picture you doing the fucking. Just… taking it.”
Ethan blinked, his ears going hot. “The fuck—?”
Mason chuckled. “I’m serious. You’d be all like—” He pitched his voice high and fake-moany, “—‘ohhh, please, be gentle!’”
Lila gave him a little shove from her spot on the couch. “Okay, chill. Don’t be an ass.”
But Cass just smirked, eyes glittering like she’d been handed a loaded gun. “No, no, he’s kinda right. I mean, look at Ethan. He’s not exactly… dominant material.”
Ethan’s stomach twisted. “Wow. Thanks.”
Cass tilted her head, pretending to think. “Mmh, yeah… I can definitely see you on your back, making those cute little noises—”
“Jesus Christ,” Ethan cut in, half laughing to save face.
“—while someone holds your wrists down,” Cass finished, ignoring him.
Mason burst out laughing. Lila rolled her eyes but didn’t step in again.
Ethan took a long pull from his beer, forcing a smirk like he wasn’t flustered out of his mind. Same as always: let them laugh, play along. Pretend the heat creeping down his neck was just embarrassment — not that his brain was already running with the image Cass had just painted, filthy and uninvited.
Cass was still smirking at him, the way a cat smirks at a mouse it’s already pinned.
“You know,” she said casually, “if Ethan was a girl, I bet he’d be one of those real easy ones. Big puppy eyes, all shy, saying ‘I’ve never done this before’ while already soaking through her panties.”
Mason barked a laugh. “Oh, for sure. The kind who says ‘stop’ but doesn’t really mean it.”
“Wow,” Ethan muttered, half under his breath.
Cass leaned forward on her beanbag, chin in her hand. “No, picture it. Little crop top that’s too small, short shorts riding up her ass, acting like she doesn’t know why everyone’s staring.”
Lila gave a small groan. “Do we have to—?”
“Yes,” Cass cut in, eyes never leaving Ethan. “And she’d be the kind of girl who moans just from someone’s hands on her hips.”
Mason grinned. “She’d have those soft, squirmy thighs you can barely keep still. Probably bite her lip and—” He made an obscene little sucking sound with his teeth.
Ethan’s face was burning now. “You guys are fucking insane.”
Cass’s grin only widened. “Oh, she’s mad. Look at her. Bet if she was a girl, she’d be so sensitive. One little touch and she’d be begging.”
Mason snorted. “Begging and making that mess you can hear.”
Ethan buried his face in his beer can, wishing he could disappear. But the heat in his chest and gut wasn’t just embarrassment — not with the way Cass’s voice dropped when she said begging.
Lila glanced at him, half-smiling like she knew exactly how far gone he was, and for a second he thought she might actually change the subject. But then Cass laughed again, tossing her hair back.
“You know what’s sad?” she said. “I think he’d make a hotter girl than half the chicks we know.”
Mason grinned. “Yeah, but she’d still be a virgin.”
That broke them into another round of laughter, and Ethan just sat there, flushed to his ears, forcing the same fake smile he always wore when they tore him apart. Pretending it didn’t make his head spin when they talked about him like that. Pretending it didn’t sound… good.
Cass wasn’t even close to done with him. She shifted on the beanbag, leaning forward with her chin in her hand, smirking like she was picking him apart piece by piece.
“Alright, let’s just say — hypothetically — if Ethan woke up tomorrow as a chick, what’s she look like?”
Mason didn’t miss a beat. “Easy. Big fucking tits. Like, bigger than her head. Tits so huge she’d have to hold ’em when she ran or they’d knock her out.”
Cass laughed, eyes still on Ethan. “Yeah, and she wouldn’t know what to do with them. Always pulling at her shirt or crossing her arms, but it’d just push them up more and make everyone stare harder.”
Lila gave a small shake of her head, the ghost of a smile on her face. “You two are sick.”
“And she’d have one of those asses that pops in yoga pants,” Mason went on, grinning. He held his hands apart like he was sizing up a basketball. “You’d hear it clap when she walked past.”
Cass snorted. “Oh my god, yes. And she’d still be shy about it — which would make it worse. Men would eat her alive. Women too.”
Ethan tried to smirk like it didn’t faze him. “Yeah, sure. Totally sounds like me.”
Cass cocked her head. “Oh, it does. You’d have that ‘too sweet to be here’ face, all blushy and flustered, and every guy in the room would want to ruin you.”
“Jesus Christ,” Ethan muttered, his ears getting hot.
“Actually,” Mason said, eyes glinting, “we could probably figure out exactly what you’d look like. Easy.”
Ethan frowned. “How?”
Mason grinned at Cass, and she suddenly snatched his phone right out of his hand.
“Hey—!”
“Shut up,” she said, already typing. “Pornhub, baby. This is for science.”
Ethan’s stomach twisted. “Oh, fuck off.”
“No, I’m serious,” Cass said, grinning wide. “We just search for the closest match. Let’s start with ‘big tits shy girl.’ That sound about right?”
Mason was laughing. “Make sure you add ‘virgin’… and maybe ‘gets ruined’ or ‘first time.’”
Ethan groaned, dragging a hand over his face. “You guys are unbelievable.”
Cass ignored him, scrolling through thumbnails like she was picking an outfit. “Oooh, here we go — she’s got your eyes. Big, innocent, like she has no idea what’s about to happen to her.”
Mason leaned over to watch. “Yeah, and those tits. Yep. That’s Ethan all over.”
“Christ—” Ethan muttered, taking a long drink of beer to hide his face.
Cass tapped a video. The screen filled with a girl on her knees, chest heaving, tits bouncing with every movement while a guy’s hand tangled in her hair. Her mouth opened, a perfect little moan spilling out of the speakers.
Mason laughed. “That’s the noise you’d make, bro. Exactly that pitch.”
Ethan tried to keep his eyes down, but the sounds filled the room, low and breathy and shameless. His cheeks burned hotter.
Cass looked over the top of the phone at him. “Yeah… you’d fit right in.”
Mason grinned. “Honestly, you’d probably end up trending.”
Ethan shook his head, muttering, “You guys are insane.” But his voice wasn’t sharp enough to hide the way his pulse was racing.
Lila watched him quietly from her spot on the couch, one brow raised, and for a second Ethan thought she might actually put an end to it. But then Cass just laughed, clicked to another clip, and turned the screen toward him again.
This time it was a girl sprawled on her back, crop top pushed up under her chin, tits spilling free as someone’s hands gripped her hips and pulled her closer. She was gasping, eyes wide, making soft little noises between breaths.
“Yep,” Cass said, tapping the screen. “That’s the face. That’s you.”
Ethan didn’t say anything. His throat felt too tight.
Cass was still glued to Mason’s phone, scrolling through Pornhub like it was her personal catalogue, and every so often she’d stop on a thumbnail just to shove it in Ethan’s face.
“Look at this one,” she said, tilting the screen toward him. “Big tits, big eyes, acting all innocent until… well, you know.”
Ethan kept his eyes on his beer. “Yeah, thanks, I get the picture.”
Mason leaned over Cass’s shoulder, grinning. “No, no, that’s totally him if he was a girl. Hell, he even has that same confused face right now.”
Cass laughed. “You mean that ‘I have no idea what’s about to happen to me but I’m still blushing like crazy’ face? Yeah.”
“Fuck off,” Ethan muttered, voice tight.
Cass clicked a video and let it play just long enough for a soft, breathy moan to come through the speakers. She raised her brows at Ethan. “Yeah, that’s the noise you’d make, too.”
Mason snorted. “She’d be on her back two minutes in, panties on the floor, eyes rolling back.”
“Jesus Christ,” Ethan groaned.
Cass leaned back against the beanbag, smirk curling slow. “You know what?” She tapped the phone against her thigh like she was making a serious point. “All this is too much work. We should just skip the small talk and summon a succubus for him.”
Ethan blinked. “…The fuck did you just say?”
“Yeah,” Mason jumped in instantly, already laughing. “Straight-up sex demon. Pops out of a puff of smoke, jumps on him, rides him until he passes out.”
Cass grinned. “At least then we know he’d die happy.”
Lila made a face, though there was a smirk tugging at her lips. “You two are ridiculous.”
Cass ignored her, leaning forward toward the coffee table. “Where’s Mason’s laptop?”
Mason pointed with his chin. “Over there. Don’t break it.”
Ethan set his beer down. “No, no, no, you’re not actually—”
Cass planted Mason’s laptop on her knees, cracked her knuckles like she was about to do serious research, and immediately started typing into the search bar: summon succubus sex ritual.
The results popped up in an instant — a messy page of clickbait titles, grainy thumbnails, and sketchy forum links.
“Oh yeah, this looks like the good shit,” Mason said sarcastically, leaning over to peek at the screen.
Cass started scrolling, eyes flicking past each entry. “Let’s see… ‘I Summoned a Succubus at 3AM — Gone Wrong’… lame. ‘Real Sex Demon Caught on Tape’… okay, if that was real she wouldn’t be wearing a fucking bra… lame.”
Ethan shook his head. “You guys are literally digging through porn-flavored creepypasta right now.”
Cass ignored him, scrolling further. “Ooh, here’s one… nope, that’s just a hentai GIF dump.” She kept going. “Forum thread titled ‘Succubi I’ve Slept With — AMA’? Yeah, sure, Chad from Oklahoma, tell me all about it. Lame.”
Mason chuckled. “Damn, this is like looking for buried treasure in a landfill.”
Cass sighed dramatically, still scrolling. “All staged, all fake… come on, internet, give me something weird.”
A moment later she stopped mid-scroll, her eyes narrowing on a link buried a few results down. The title stood out from the rest — not in all caps, no clickbait exclamation marks, just a simple, ominous name:
Velvetsin’s Mirror Rite — Awaken the Flesh You Were Meant to Have.
Cass’s grin curled slow and sharp, like a cat spotting prey. “Well… hello.”
Mason leaned closer, squinting at the screen. “‘Awaken the flesh you were meant to have’?” His grin spread. “Ohhh, we’re talking transformation sex demon shit now. This is getting good.”
Cass tapped the trackpad but didn’t click yet, glancing over at Ethan with a gleam in her eyes. “Bet this one’s got your name all over it.”
Ethan frowned. “I don’t even know what the fuck that means.”
Mason smirked. “Means whatever’s hiding in your pants probably isn’t staying the same after this.”
Ethan frowned. “What does that even—”
Cass finally clicked, the screen going black for a second before loading into a site that looked… wrong. No ads, no flashy banners — just a pitch-black background, blood-red lettering, and a grainy photo of a tall mirror surrounded by candles. A pale, half-naked woman knelt before it, her reflection in the glass… different.
Lila shifted uncomfortably. “Okay, that’s… kind of creepy.”
Cass scrolled down, eyes bright. “Oh my god, listen to this. ‘The supplicant must bare themselves before the mirror. An offering of lust must be given into a vessel of copper. Speak the words as the mirror shows your truth form.’”
Mason burst out laughing. “Translation: strip, jerk off into a bowl, say some magic words, boom — you’re a big-titted demon chick.”
Cass grinned like she’d just found buried treasure. “That’s exactly it. This is perfect.”
The site loaded slow, like it was trying to make them work for it. The background was pitch black, the text a jagged, deep red that almost glowed against the darkness. Every image looked like it had been taken on some old camcorder — grainy, oversaturated, and just a little wrong.
The first picture was a copper bowl sitting in the middle of a chalk-drawn circle. The next was a close-up of someone’s hands sprinkling some kind of powder into it. Then came a blurry, dimly lit shot of a tall mirror surrounded by candles — and in the reflection, the figure kneeling in front of it didn’t quite match the person in the room.
Cass tilted the screen so everyone could see, a grin already tugging at her lips. “Ohhh, this is so much better than that YouTube crap.”
Lila shifted on the couch, frowning. “This looks… I don’t know. Like the kind of site that gives you a virus.”
“Good,” Mason said, leaning in like he was getting front-row seats. “Means we’re in the real freak zone now.”
Cass scrolled, her finger moving slow on the trackpad like she was savoring each reveal. More pictures followed — grainy close-ups of bare thighs in candlelight, long streaks of red wax dripped down skin, and one shot of a mirror where the reflection showed curves that the real body didn’t have.
“Oh, here we go…” Cass said, her voice dipping into something mockingly seductive as she started reading from the page. “‘The supplicant must bare themselves before the mirror. All garments removed, all shame left behind.’”
Her eyes flicked to Ethan, letting the words hang.
Mason grinned instantly. “Translation: strip naked, bro. Not down to your boxers — bare. Birthday suit. We gotta see the goods.”
Ethan scoffed, looking away. “Yeah, that’s not happening.”
Cass didn’t stop. “‘An offering of lust must be given into a vessel of copper, to be placed before the glass.’” She looked up at him with a wicked smirk. “An offering of lust. Take a wild guess what they mean.”
Mason laughed so hard he almost fell out of his chair. “Dude, it’s literally telling you to beat off into a bowl. Like… cum in it. Handful of nut, right there in the circle.”
Lila wrinkled her nose, but she was smirking too. “Wow. Subtle.”
Cass’s voice went lower as she read the next part. “‘Speak the words as the mirror shows your truth form. Let the reflection become flesh. Do not look away before the change is complete.’”
Mason raised a brow. “The ‘truth form’? Oh, fuck yes. You know exactly what that means. You’re about to find out you were always supposed to be a shy little thing with huge tits and a needy pussy.”
Ethan’s grip tightened around his beer can. “You guys are insane.”
Cass just grinned wider. “Mmm, I can already picture it. You, all naked in front of the mirror, tits spilling over your hands, thighs pressed together, moaning while you watch yourself change.”
Mason chuckled darkly. “Bet she’d be dripping before the ritual even finished.”
Ethan forced a laugh, but his ears were bright red. “Yeah, okay.”
Cass scrolled down to the “Ritual Requirements” list, reading it like she was doing a dramatic grocery run.
“Full-length mirror — check. Candles — obviously. Chalk — Mason’s little cousin left some in the garage. Copper bowl…” She paused, eyes glittering. “…we can use that fancy mixing bowl your mom keeps in the cabinet.”
“Yeah,” Mason added, “the one she only takes out for holidays. That thing’s gonna be full of your cum by midnight.”
Lila groaned, shaking her head. “You guys are disgusting.”
“Don’t pretend you’re not curious,” Cass shot back. “Think about it. We follow all this bullshit, the mirror starts glowing or whatever, and bam — Ethan’s standing there as his ‘truth form.’ And from the way he’s squirming right now, I’m thinking it’s a she.”
Mason leaned forward, elbows on his knees, grinning right at Ethan. “And I really want to see what she looks like. I bet she’s got that same flustered face you’re wearing now, but with tits bouncing every time she breathes.”
Cass smirked, holding the screen toward him. “So? What do you say? Too scared to find out who you really are?”
Ethan shook his head, but the heat crawling down his neck betrayed him. “You’re fucking nuts.”
Cass tilted her head, all mock sympathy. “Mmm… or maybe you just don’t want us to see how bad you’d love it.”
Ethan shook his head. “No. Absolutely not.”
Cass cocked her head. “Why not? Scared it might work?”
Mason joined in. “Come on, man. You’ve been talking big all night. Here’s your chance to put your dick where your mouth is.”
“I haven’t been—” Ethan started, but Cass cut him off.
“You are too chicken. Admit it.”
“I’m not—”
“Then prove it.”
Lila let out a sigh, half amused, half like she knew they weren’t going to let him out of this. “You guys are really gonna make him…?”
Cass’s smirk was pure challenge. “He doesn’t have to. Unless, of course, he’s too scared to find out what his ‘truth form’ actually is…”
Mason chuckled low. “Bet it’s exactly what we said earlier. Big tits, fat ass, shy face. The kind that gets ruined in the first five minutes.”
Ethan’s stomach knotted, heat climbing up his neck. “You guys are insane.”
Ethan took a long drink from his beer, more to buy time than because he wanted it.
“Look, this is all just… gibberish,” he said finally, nodding toward the laptop. “Some random shady-ass site probably made by a bored pervert with too much free time. This isn’t real. None of this shit is real.”
Cass leaned back, grinning. “Yeah, no shit it’s not real. That’s not the point.”
Mason was already chuckling. “Exactly. We’re not saying it’s gonna work, man — we’re saying we want to watch you stand in front of a mirror naked, jerk into a bowl, and say magic words like an idiot.”
Lila snorted into her drink. “It’s basically a party trick. With more nudity.”
Ethan’s jaw tightened. “Yeah, well… thanks, but I’ll pass on being tonight’s entertainment.”
Cass’s grin only widened. “Aww, come on. What’s the worst that could happen? Either nothing happens and we all laugh, or—” she leaned in slightly, lowering her voice, “—we get a show that’ll make tonight unforgettable.”
Mason grinned, picking up the thread. “Think of it as a challenge. You’re always the one sitting out, always avoiding anything remotely risky. We’re giving you a chance to prove you’re not completely vanilla.”
Ethan shook his head. “This isn’t risky, it’s just stupid.”
“Exactly,” Mason said, smirking. “And you can’t even do stupid without chickening out.”
Cass laughed sharply. “Yeah, the only thing scary here is that you might actually finish in front of us faster than you expect.”
Lila sighed, trying to be the voice of reason. “You guys are just trying to humiliate him.”
“Obviously,” Cass said with zero shame, then turned back to Ethan. “So? You in or are you gonna keep hiding behind ‘it’s not real’ like that’s an excuse?”
Mason grinned wider. “If it’s not real, then you’ve got nothing to lose. Unless you’re scared to let us see what you’re packing.”
Ethan rolled his eyes, but the way he gripped the beer tighter made Cass’s smirk sharpen. They had him cornered, and they both knew it.
Ethan sat there, trying to smirk it off, but the pause after Cass’s “sluttier” comment stretched too long. They weren’t moving on. Both Cass and Mason were just staring at him now, like a pair of cats watching a mouse that was already cornered.
Mason leaned forward, elbows on his knees, grin wide enough to look dangerous. “So what’s it gonna be, man? You in, or are you just gonna keep proving us right that you’re too much of a little chicken shit?”
Cass arched a brow. “Yeah, I think we’ve got our answer. He’s afraid. Afraid he’ll like it when those tits start swelling out and bouncing in his face every time he moves… afraid he’ll look down and see that cute little slit all pink and wet instead of his sad, limp dick.”
Ethan frowned. “I’m not—”
“Not what?” Mason cut in, smirking. “Not scared? Bullshit. You’re terrified. Terrified we’re gonna see you standing there with a pair of tits you could fuck between, an ass that jiggles if you breathe too hard, and a needy little pussy so wet you can hear it.”
Ethan’s ears burned instantly, and he gripped his beer tighter. “Jesus, dude—”
Cass grinned. “Oh, I love this. He’s blushing already, and we haven’t even lit a candle.”
Mason didn’t stop. “Hell, man, you can’t even get laid as you are now. What’s the worst that could happen? You end up a chick who actually gets some? That’d be a massive upgrade for you.”
Cass let out a wicked laugh. “Yeah, maybe then you’d finally find out what it’s like to come with someone else in the room.”
Mason tilted his head. “Or in you.”
Lila groaned, but didn’t step in — she knew they’d just plow right over her if she tried.
Ethan muttered, “It’s not real, anyway—”
“Exactly!” Mason jumped on it immediately. “It’s not real, so you’ve got no excuse. Unless deep down you want it to be real and that’s what’s making you squirm right now.”
Cass leaned in, her tone syrupy and cruel. “Ohhh, yeah… I think that’s it. I think a part of you wants to stand in front of that mirror, strip bare, stroke yourself until you’re moaning, and then watch your own reflection twist and swell into something soft and fuckable.”
Mason grinned like he’d hit the jackpot. “And the best part? We’ll be right here to see every second. Every jiggle. Every twitch. Every gasp when you feel that pussy for the first time.”
Ethan groaned and set his beer down a little too hard. “Fine,” he snapped, sharper than he intended. “If it’ll shut you two up, I’ll do your stupid ritual.”
Mason’s grin spread into something feral. “That’s the spirit.”
Cass leaned back, satisfied. “Good boy. Let’s get this set up. I wanna see if you can keep a straight face when those pants come off.”
“You’re not—” Ethan started.
“Oh, we’re watching,” Cass cut in, standing up and snapping the laptop closed. “That’s the whole point of the dare.”
Mason clapped him on the shoulder, grinning like a wolf. “Don’t worry, man — we’ll be gentle. Well… at least until you’ve got tits big enough to grab.”
Ethan shot him a glare, but it was hollow. They had him, and all three of them knew there was no way he could back out now without giving them a year’s worth of ammo.
Mason wasn’t letting him off the hook just because Ethan had agreed. He leaned back in his chair, a slow, lazy grin spreading across his face like he was already undressing Ethan’s “truth form” in his head.
“Y’know,” he started, dragging out the words, “if this thing actually worked… I’d rail you. No hesitation.”
Ethan blinked. “What the fuck—?”
Mason smirked wider. “Yeah. I’d bend your new ass over that mirror, get a good handful of those fat hips, and just thrust until you couldn’t even think straight. Slap that big ass and watch it bounce while my cock’s buried deep in your brand-new pussy.”
Cass burst into laughter, clapping her hands once like she couldn’t believe he’d actually said it out loud.
“Oh my god, Mason,” she said between laughs.
Lila groaned but she was smiling too. “You’re disgusting.”
Mason kept going, unfazed. “Nah, I’m serious. You’d be moaning like a pornstar, tits swinging with every hit. I’d pull your hair just to hear you gasp.”
Ethan’s face was turning crimson. “Jesus Christ—”
“Oh, and I wouldn’t stop until you came on my cock,” Mason said, leaning forward now. “Make you forget you were ever a guy. You’d be begging me to keep going.”
Cass shook her head, grinning. “You would look good begging.”
Ethan shifted uncomfortably, his grip tightening on his beer. “I’m already doing the damn ritual,” he muttered, his voice smaller than he wanted it to be. “You don’t have to… keep saying that shit.”
Mason smirked like he’d just scored a point. “What, can’t handle the idea of actually enjoying it? Afraid you’ll get too into it?”
Ethan looked down at the floor, his ears blazing. “Just… drop it, alright?”
Cass tilted her head, faux-innocent. “Aww, are we embarrassing you? That’s cute. You’ll be way redder than this if it actually works.”
“I’m serious,” Ethan said, sharper now but still meek under the weight of their grins. “I’ll do it, just—enough.”
Mason raised his hands in mock surrender, though his grin didn’t fade. “Fine, fine. We’ll save the rest for when we’re watching.”
Cass reached over and gave Ethan a light pat on the shoulder. “Relax. It’s just a stupid dare. You strip, do the steps, nothing happens, and we all get a laugh out of it. End of story.”
“Exactly,” Mason said, already heading for the shelves to dig out candles. “It’s not like some horny demon’s gonna crawl out of the mirror and turn you into a cock-hungry little slut with tits out to here.” He gestured in front of his chest in big, obscene circles.
Cass smirked. “Yeah, after all… what could possibly go wrong?”
They both laughed, the sound light and careless, as if this was just another late-night joke that would end in a story they’d tell for years.
Ethan tried to force a laugh along with them, but his chest felt tight and hot, the weight of their words lingering far longer than he wanted to admit.
To be continued...
Comments
FemmeForge
Yeah, they are jerks. You are very attentive. But they will have their part in the story, but will have their twist lol
Tishers
Cass is the only friend I would keep. The other two can get the hell out of my apartment. They were never your friends.
FemmeForge
Oh man! Thanks so much! I highly appreciate that you love my smut stories. That means a lot to me and you are very welcome in my patreon. Just wait for more 😉
Fratspin
Just wanted to say that I'm a new subscriber and absolutely love all of your stories
