ComicPop!
patreon
Which thumbnail do you like best?
🕑 Added 2023-05-11 20:27:38 +0000 UTCRain or no rain?
Comments
Christopher Wolf
NO rain...and HELL YEAH for this story. I first read it in Marvel: Five Fabulous Decades of the World's Greatest Comics
Sofia Trug
It's hard to tell it's rain and not just a grey filter.
Galahad’s Comics
Rain
Popeye F
No rain
Shodd Rivers
The rain adds a bit more dread
Chris Hacker
No rain looks best IMO
SecretbossSauce
I think 2
Blinky
1 looks better on desktop, 2 is better on mobile. You know better than me which platform most of us consume your videos on.
Myles_EXVS
2nd thumbnail is better
Bran J
No rain, to me it just makes the image darker on mobile
Veki
2. I agree with Justin Oakley. I like the rain but I don't know if it'll show up right on smaller screens. Before I enlarged it for the preview, I couldn't tell there was rain. Just that it was darker.
Aaron Cabe
I want to say one and on my big pc screen[also my tv so fairly big] on patreon where its pretty big anyway sure but on phone and notifications or home screen size I think some of the above people are right in that it just may make it look less bright and I have no clue how the brightness of a thumbnail would effect the youtube recommend algorithm and/or if people are less like to click because of brightness. there's a freakonomics subject for ya
Justin Oakley
The rain effect is hard to see, so I would say go with the second thumbnail.
Ninja Josh
Rain
Logan Shirley
I like the rain, but I feel like no rain is likely to get more eyes on it
Sadie Mullin
I appreciate the idea of rain.. but it is a tad darker.
Francis Dela Cruz
Just rain on ben... jokes aside, the thumbnail looks brighter without the rain
Kurensik
The rain is hard to see. I think if you brightened it it would be more clear. That being said, I definitely like the rain idea.
Vance Cunningham
Rain is hard to notice, just looks like a dulled image
Judah Gregory
1
