ComicPop!
patreon
Collecting data on the new thumbnails
🕑 Added 2024-07-05 22:31:52 +0000 UTCSo obviously we started with three, but that was just because there were three options. We're never going to do a text-less version, so it's really just these two versions. One, which is the classic, and Two, which is the one with the logo in the top corner and the cover taking the entire background. Anyway, I'd love to know your preference. Feel free to refer to them as old or new or whatever.
Comments
Nathan Kelleher
While the couch missing in the new one is kind of a bummer, I like seeing the members front and center (maybe even do the poses still). The title being off in the corner isn't a bother for me personally, and I think it looks more like a regular YouTube thumbnail. I like the new one, but I'll be clicking on it regardless though, so take that for what you will.
KenBNL
I like the classic look
Ninja Josh
Larger text. It's easier to identify what I'm looking at in a sea of other thumbnails.
Billy Vidal Ruiz III
Left /classic the centered title just hits plus the couch 👍🏻
David Acevedo
Left my man!
David Nelson
Keep the couch!
Patrick Mocella
I think the logo in the centre looks a lot better on mobile especially
Drew A. Walker
Classic for sure. Really looking forward to this episode!
Jabezcreed
The left. The couch is iconic!
Christopher Usler
Classic, hands down
Bran J
I have to be honest, while I like experimenting with the design format. At a quick glance I noticed my eyesight is immediately drawn to Sal’s face in the new design while the old design puts the focus squarely on the world “Wolverine”. Maybe the new design could work well with a more dynamic pose? Or a Halloween episode with costumes? Or artwork like the Simpsons episode Just not feeling it on this one.
Ant Testing Ground
Always going to love the old style, but I like the new thumbnails. Only issue I have with it is no couch. I would say either leave the couch in or only do the top half of you guys like how you did the justice league one last time
BigBusta
the classic thumbnail makes you stand out from a lot of other comicbook channels and gives you more of an idea of what you will get. Number 2 looks more generic and not really eye catching.
TheWolfJack
The new (right) thumbnail feels like you all are floating unsupported. I think the old (left) thumbnail looks better.
Justin Oakley
I kinda like the old thumbnail.
Comic junkie
New
Sofia Trug
Classic is definitely my preferred. There are a bunch of videos with thumbnails of zoomed-in comic book covers. When I see the couch I immediately know it's Back Issues.
Geoffrey Thorne
left, I think. but I'm crap at marketing so, bear that in mind.
Blinky
I've got really bad vision and often browse YouTube on my phone, so I'd definitely go for the one on the left; much easier to read, esecially at a glance.
Christopher Wolf
I personally prefer the left (old version).
Lex Larsen
I think the new one works better at stimulating like one thing in the user. Like the color of the background lights couldve been influencing ppl subsconsciously or whatever bc (ewww i hate green/magenta/blue etc) So having it be something from the book might trigger just the thought of "OH I LOVE THAT SHIT"
Rami Darwish
The classic, only because it shows the studio, which gives an idea of the setting to someone who is familiar to the show
BatVader
1, you can see the title from a thumbnail size clearly
Aaron Cabe
I get why you may want the right, as it may hit algorithm better, but im partial to the left because the colorful background
