Leaqio.com
Jcb112 from patreon
Jcb112 patreon

Wearing Power Armor to a Magic School (89/?) Revised Version 1

🕑 Added 2024-07-07 21:30:19 +0000 UTC

Comments

Destinum

Bench press is definitely not just upper body; a very significant portion of force comes from the legs.

Destinum

I'm fine with Ping's weights, since he's both an alien and (presumably) not used to this type of training. Emma's absolute limit being 75kg sounded about right, but then she somehow managed to push 100 after that? Not only would this make her basically a professional weightlifter, but just sentence-wise... how do you go 33% beyond your supposed limit?

ISB-76-TK338

Augmentation is specifically banned. Emma is about as close to baseline as you can get. In fact I think she is discounting maybe some super vaccines or something.

Michael Halpern

also weight, just because the suit assist counteracts some of the weight from Emma's armor, doesn't mean it isn't there, in the bench press she's working against gravity, in the pull, she's working at least partially with gravity.

Michael Halpern

not really two major factors, bench press is upper body only, while the pull can be with the full body, and Ping likely over strained himself in the bench press

Michael Halpern

well they could have flipped a bunch of epigenetic switches to make her more predisposed to getting stronger

Michael Halpern

I suspect it happened between chapters,

Blake S

When was that? The bird asdaulting drone chapter?

Duplicitous Michael

because unless Emma has any augmentations, then Human anatomy shouldn’t have really changed that much in a mere 1,000 years. And it’s just plain realistic.

Blake S

Shes allso got the extra grippy boot and glove grip pads, made of materials that the nexus or even the library hasnt seen before. Shes got the literal home depot high grip construction gloves and boots technology.

G

None of which has been established in the story. Ping is established as a large Bull person and Emma a Thai woman. Technique cannot overcome 100lb weight difference in what is a test of strength.

Thisisanick

They have space elevators, rings, warp drives and stuff, it's not a far stretch that human body would got improved a bit as well. Also, in the explicit case of Emma, top military training for top secret mission is involved.

Michael Halpern

i suspect Emma will be doing some prechecks for her flight pack during the break, probably better to just schedule meetings im not concerned about them knowing the upper limits of the enhancements, the bigger issue would be her fab equipment, and likely the drones

Michael Halpern

different events i suspect that there will be some vertical mobility involved in at least the endurance bit, designed to tire out the contestants as fast as possible even with magic aid

Michael Halpern

"Ramming speed"

SoylentPudding

I'm loving the story and really enjoyed the endurance portion. The strength contest still feels off though. Emma losing the bench press but barely pulling the sword still feels a little too inconsistent. I looked up the US Army combat fitness test to get a baseline for Emma. I believe a score of 70 out of 100 points per exercise is the minimum for "heavy" specialties, which likely applies to power armor. Emma wouldn't be choses for this assignment if she does the bare minimum, but also her training probably did not leave a lot of extra time for additional workouts. I don't remember her exact age, but I'm going with 17-21 since she's a cadet. I'm assuming 1000 years of exercise science has done more to prolong the amount of time someone can maintain youthful fitness standards rather than creating crazy genetically altered transhumanist performance levels. The scores are discrete, not continuous, so I went with the lowest possible score above 80 and rounded down where possible to get pretty numbers in kilograms. Emma should be able to: -Deadlift 70 kgs for 3 repetitions. -Throw a 5kg medicine ball backwards overhead for 5.8m -Perform 27 hand release pushups in 2 minutes. (in between each pushup the soldier lays on the ground and extends their arms straight out off the ground in a T-pose) -Sprint/Drag/Carry overall time of 2:28 minutes. (sprint 25m and back, drag a 40 kg sled 25m and back, 25m lateral and back, carry 2 20kg kettle bells 25m and back, 25m sprint and back) -2:35 plank -19:17 2 mile run A couple thoughts as a result. I'd believe Aurus is the kind of bro who bicep curls in the squat rack and skips leg day. So he could beat Emma on the bench press no problem, but for the sword he has bad technique and is trying to brace his legs and pull it with his arms. Emma instead braces her arms and pulls with her hips and legs getting just enough of a mechanical advantage to make up the difference in raw strength. I was once at a county fair with that hammer the lever to launch the weight towards a bell game. I saw a bunch of muscular dudes swing with all their might and barely get halfway up because it was all arm strength. Then my tiny 5'2" firefighter friend who grew up chopping firewood nearly hit the bell because she knew how to drive the swing with her legs and hips, not her arms. Also Ping is probably absolutely gassed at this point whereas Emma still has plenty of endurance left. So Ping is lifting well below his one rep max from fatigue, which isn't enough to make up for a mostly still fresh Emma. My wildest idea is inspired by the ancient Greek Pankration. Expand the strength event to include pull ups, climbing a wall, navigating monkey bars, or something else that will play to Emma's primate body structure and superior strength to weight ratio. Alternatively a hybrid strength-endurance event like the Sprint/Drag/Carry from the army test. Emma can win that one allowing Auris to out muscle her on the sword in the stone challenge. Auris can act like Emma lost the bet because she tied, and then Chiska can announce there is a traditional tie-breaker, wrestling. Whatever size and strength advantage Ping has, I imagine Emma is significantly better trained in hand to hand combat. She could taunt ping into a stupid, aggressive bullrush and surprise him with a ringout before he knows what happened.

Blake S

This history lesson shows their early ancestors used sticks and pointy rock technology, they didnt allways have magic as their go to, and it would have only been available to those gifted in it. Throwing would have 100% been a evoloutionary advantage. And clearly something that all the other relams struggled with.

Michael Halpern

Chiska chose the challenges, but i don't think it was to benefit elves, rather to put everyone at a relatively equal disadvantage. Persistence hunting is rare in nature, on land excluding hominids, its canines in some environments and ambush predators after a failed ambush sure the elves might have good endurance based on convergent evolution, but they would still have to train for it, and with magic to help, they likely never needed to excel at unassisted throwing, for humans a 5km jog is entry level and good weight distribution in armor design can allow for quite heavy armor to not be cumbersome

Michael Halpern

biological capability averages dont change much once you have advanced enough to null out any evolutionary pressures

SoylentPudding

I choose to believe she was looping the Terminator 2 theme the entire time she was chasing Ping.

PrivatePershing

I mean u could just attribute it to modern lifting techniques and modern medicine/habits

Thisisanick

Why would average stats from contemporary year 2k make still sense in ~3k utopia?

Thisisanick

You are comparing one alien to another.. for all we know Ping could be from lower gravity world or just don't actually train much, as a noble. What is more, contemporary standards could be utterly obsolete in the far future, superior supplements, centuries of evolution under better diets, gene therapies, even in the last few generations, decent diet increased average height greatly.

Thisisanick

Guess they have better supplements in the far future.. also, contemporary generations already have huge increase in average height mostly thanks to just decent diet.

Steve

Yo, what kind of songs was Emma listening to?

BoneBreakerPL

Running and javelin throws. EMMA: I'm a human. This is what I was breed for!

Thomas Mascotto

There could be two reasons why Emma wins the sword pull. First auris while on the bench could go overboard with his weights to show superiority. Thus weakening him for the final round. Second she could the sword an hug and using her amour for protection and her legs for power she could get it up those final inches.

Michael Halpern

Our bodies are also designed for climbing things pushing may be easier than pulling, but we can pull things pretty well to, including our own weight up a branch. also note, Emma was using her whole body to pull the sword, and Auris may have been a little sore still from pushing past his limits in endurance and weight.

Duplicitous Michael

This is better, but tbh in a matter of unassisted strength Emma should’ve been washed in every category except the Javelin throw since our anatomy is basically designed to be able to throw things far and fast. Auris would easily be able to clear the bench and sword pull. Unless you want to chalk it up to muscular atrophy, which could make some sense. Overall a tip with weights, is that the average Adult Woman who trains regularly can bench 70-100kgs, and can do 100kgs for reps.

Blade Tech

Glad the criticism could help

OrangeSpaceProgram

I feel like Emma should get crushed on the bench press (figuratively) and she should barely win on the sword pull and that ought to be chalked up to bone structure alone.

G

Good chapter but the sttrength part is WAY off still. Use this resource to get an idea of how far off you are: https://strengthlevel.com/strength-standards/bench-press/lb Emma and Ping are in completely different weight classes unless she's competing at the Olympic level ( which you haven't established) and Ping is sickly (which you've established against) there's no way they should even be close. And it's not 20lb difference in weight it's literally at least a factor of 2. There's no believable way Emma is close in the bench or the sword, it shouldn't even be close.

Blake S

I cant wait for next chapter to watch emma clown on some magic nobles but allso i want to see her and thalmins interactions after this. Athlete to warrior as it were. Feel like he would have some fun things to say. Allso how weird emmas feets must seem to any outside observer not in the know, she runs 5 kilometers in hundreds if not thousands of kilo power armor but struggles to lift a hundred kilo rock. Allso Allso im betting the elves chose these chalenges because they pair well with elven biology. Throwing and endurance racing especially. Since we can safefully assume thier biology grants them similar strengths as humans due to their physical similarities. Pretty much theh chose these to either put down or clown on the other races because you know making everyone play a game that only they can win is kind of thier whole deal.

Michael Halpern

I like Ilunor's "intuition" (if Emma telling him her species evolved for persistence hunting counts as intuition, rather than insider trading)

Patrick Booth

This rewrite was a significant improvement from the previous iteration. Well done!

I Dare Korval

I wonder if during the break Emma will be explaining to her peer group (and if others over hear her, well then that happens) that she reduced the armor assistance to effectivelty cancel itself out as a hinderance and that what happened was effectively all just her. NOW, she's going to use the suits augmentation for what's next (still all without mana). I do hope she doesn't go all out since it would be unwise to let the Nexus become aware of the true upper limits of her armor's enhancements.

I Dare Korval

I wonder if it will all be the exact same events, or new ones. I can see redoing the existing ones from a comparative perspective, but it might make the next chapter a bit repeatative.

Jcb112

I was moreso aiming for advanced due to her military training hence why I chose 75kg as the upper limits of what she's used to, but the later weights she was using when she was trying to match Auris was pushing what she normally can handle! :D However, I might tweak the weights just a bit further as weightlifting is a topic that I'm not too familiar with! :D

Nom Nom Bacon

According to this website, she's an elite: https://strengthlevel.com/strength-standards/bench-press "Elite Stronger than 95% of lifters. An elite lifter has dedicated over five years to become competitive at strength sports." Damn Emma is strong af for a 19 years old girl, I didn't know she was training for the Olympics :P

ThomasMC

Love the changes overall, reads very well; sorry for nitpicking

ThomasMC

Auris took the ‘lead’ by this point, a smug laugh erupting from his maw as he celebrated the defeat of his mortal enemy… Suggestion: Replacement for maw (I picture sharp teeth at the word, not bull-like)

The Walrus Transcendent

Damn! My man literally going "More weight!".

ThomasMC

A sword… that was currently being fought between Ilunor and Rostarion Suggestion: being fought over between

Jcb112

Thank you! That was originally the intent as I was leading up towards the sword in the stone being a tie breaker! However the original version was a bit muddied in that prior edits of the strength contest managed to slip through with the previous version of the bench pressing resulting in a tie rather than in a loss. That's why I felt like I needed to immediately remedy that with a revision! :D

ThomasMC

Gumigo and Qiv topped at about twenty-five kilograms. Suggestion: topped out at

Matt Null

Glad to see an author willing to concede little victory points once in a while to antagonistic forces to add some good amounts of tension to the scene.

ThomasMC

But it was enough to smash the class right out of the water. If I remember correctly its either blow out of the water or smash out of the park, could be wrong tho

Jcb112

It's been added in! Thank you for catching that! :D

ThomasMC

“Since the strength portion consists of three individual challenges, the Rite of Challenges states that at least two out of three must be ... (won?) ; I think there is a word missing

Pierre Florendo

Thank you! Clears up a lot.

OrangeSpaceProgram

Woo! More in the same weekend!


More Creators