Leaqio.com
Jcb112 from patreon
Jcb112 patreon

Wearing Power Armor to a Magic School (89/?) Revised Version 2

🕑 Added 2024-07-13 21:14:32 +0000 UTC

Comments

Bradiation

First up, theirs the fact that a culture that developed with magic and with different species (including some species with flight) would probably pick different standards to base their measurements off (I grant the base 10 thing here immediately). So what standard did we choose, and why did we choose it? Well, this is the beginning of the scientific revolution (something that does not happen to alien friends), and we realise the base ten thing is probably a good idea, thus the Frenchie's decide a meter should be "one ten-millionth of the distance from the North Pole to the Equator". Ok, so assuming the aliens decide to use this same metric, the literal size difference of their planet would produce a different meter. Best case scenario I would say the Alien Meter would be within 5% of our meter i.e. 95cm. I will get back to this 95 cm's later. Their is an additional critical problem, the aliens almost certainly wouldn't base their basic unit of measurement off of a natural phenomenon like the size of a single planet. Remember their whole ideology is anti-naturalist (note, almost all early scientists are naturalists), they don't want to utilize nature like us humans do, they want to dominate it with civilisation using the tools of magic. Thus their measurements would probably be based of something fundamental to Magic, like the circumference of their emperors balls or something. Infact, if you wanted to go full Lysenkoism I could argue that the Aliens would throw away the a base 10 system altogether because it is the "natural" system of mathematics, and the whole goal of civilisation is to cease the natural back for ourselves. However, assuming they keep the base 10 system, I would still guestimate that an "Alien Meter" could be anywhere from 50% smaller than our Meter to 500% bigger. The only reason the margin isn't bigger here is because the "Elves" are so anatomically similar to humans. Now lets go back to that 95cm for every alien meter I gave earlier. As we a working in a linear space (don't get me started on 3 dimensional stuff) 1 Alien km will be 95% of 1 Earth km. Our intrepid space marine ran 5 full laps. Each lap the Earth km will become 5% more out of sink compared to Alien km. Thus by the final lap, the start point would of shifted 25% around the track. by the way, the reason I give the 5% is because I used to work at a 100m long pool that was built back when Australia used Imperial, thus the pool was actually 105m long. Whilst in reality we just lied and said it was 100m long, the sheer number of times I had long distance swimmers tell me that they performed worse at out pool than other pools is pretty astonishing, to the point where they thought we had some sort of chemical in our pool that made them perform worse. i.e. they actually mind fucked themselves into weird conspiracy theories all because of this small difference in distance Now, if this story is Hard Science Fiction, I would argue that our author should include a comment about how annoyed Emma is that 5 laps equaled 4.68km exactly, and that made her OCD go nuts. If its pussy ass Soft Science Fiction then the star trek route of just ignore the problem is probably the best Btw, if you still think I'm wrong, your hypothesis can be tested pretty easily. Their are multiple different measuring systems around the world throughout history. Just take some standard "sport stadium" lengths of each of these societies and see if they are roughly the same length. E.g. compare a 1000 meter running track, to one seen in Greece's OG Olympic games. My guess is that the numbers would be in the 50% to 500% range not the 5% error range, but that's why we have hypotheses, so that I can prove myself wrong after spending a whole hour writing this response (I would do this now, but I haven't slept in 36 hours, I might do it tomoz if I can be bothered) EDIT** Just noticed I wrote a half a fucking dissertation here, good luck understanding my sleep deprived incoherent ramblings. I didn't even write the paragraphs in order, in an attempt to make it even harder to understand.

Michael Halpern

Most measurement systems (distance in particular) are at least indirectly traced to the body, while it being exactly the same as metric is unlikely, its not exactly a coincidence that a meter and yard are so close. So its likely they used the elven body as a basis, base 10 as well because of the number of digits on the hand. it might not be an exactly 1km loop, but it's likely within a close enough margin for EVI to fudge it for the sake of operator readability.

Bradiation

I might be missing something here, but did you say that the track is exactly 1km long? Shouldn't the magic space aliens have a different unit of measurement that makes the track some weird length?

Nul Atlas

JCB good job on the rewrite, while the original had a flow to it, this is much more fitting to the flow and pacing. As always, I love your work, keep it up, but don't burn yourself out.

SoylentPudding

Alas another point for the theory that elves are just humans with mana.

SoylentPudding

JCB, nothing to apologize for. We're all here because of how enthralling we find this story. I think I can safely say we all appreciate the grace with which you accept our feedback and that we're glad you're doing what it takes to put out the beat story you could possibly write.

Michael Halpern

Emma just needs a DNA sample to determine if its convergent evolution or common ancestry

Tainted_But_Thriving

The comparison to elves was phenomenal. I love the consistent theme of humans look like elves which has been brought up multiple times. Really cool

Canpinter

definitely picking up some "elves are superior" propaganda from pings comments, combined with some stuff from history class i'm guessing the nexus has a lot of built in racism.

Jcb112

Thank you so much for the kind words and for your understanding! I genuinely do appreciate it! Also thank you so much for catching that! I've made the appropriate edits! :D

Wumpy

This version flows so much better. Good job. Even if it gives me anxiety that I will not get to read the magical portion tommorow. :D But needs must and hats off to you. Suggestion: and a series weight lifting benches. .> and a series of weight lifting benches.

ThomasMC

ontempt or scorn but outright anxiousness in the bull’s eyes. Suggestion: anxiety

Michael Halpern

I get the feeling Emma's going to be Chiska's favorite student, i think she'd really appreciate the sentiment of "taking the impossible as a challenge"

Michael Halpern

I mean Ping isn't wrong, on either it not being fair or Emma being elf like, just not necessarily in the way he thinks.

Jcb112

Thank you so much for the kind words! I was genuinely so worried since I wasn't sure how this would be received. I personally think this is for the best for the overall flow of the story and for both aspects of the challenge to be able to have enough time and attention put into them so they both are compelling in their own rights! I did indeed take the criticisms to heart because they were very much constructive in nature and helped me to better tune the chapter to be what it was supposed to be! :D Again thank you so much for the kind words and I hope everyone else will also be okay with these revisions! :D

ethan

Don't apologize Jcb112. You are simply using the platform you chose to it's fullest affect. It's also heartening seeing how positively you've responded to the criticisms. KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK 💪


More Creators